Heat exchangers are key components of thermal energy conversion systems, however, their optimal design is still based on reduced order models relying on semi-empirical heat transfer correlations. CFD-based design optimization emerged as a viable method to provide a significant improvement in performance at an affordable cost. This study presents a framework to optimize multiple heat transfer surfaces concurrently using the adjoint method. The heat transfer surfaces are parametrized using a CAD-based parametrization method, and their performance is evaluated using a RANS solver complemented by its discrete adjoint counterpart for gradient computation. The optimization framework is applied to minimize the pressure drop across a bare-tube heat exchanger while constraining the heat transfer rate. Two variants of the same optimization problem are formulated: in the first one, the sensitivities are averaged and the tubes are constrained to maintain the same shape, while in the second variant, the shape of the tubes can vary, resulting in an optimum solution with non-identical tube shapes. The results show that the optimized geometry reduces the pressure drop by 19% if the tube shapes are identical, and by 25% in the case of non-identical shapes, compared to the baseline. To identify the physical mechanisms contributing to the fluid-dynamic losses, entropy generation along the flow path was investigated. The results reveal that the major loss reduction observed for the case of non-identical tube shapes is due to the better thermo-hydraulic performance of the first and last tubes.@en

The use of mixtures as working fluids of organic Rankine cycle (ORC) waste heat recovery (WHR) power plants has been proposed in the past to improve the matching between the temperature profile of the hot and the cold streams of condensers and evaporators, thus to possibly increase the energy conversion efficiency of the system. The goal of this study is to assess the benefits in terms of efficiency, environmental (GWP) and operational safety (flammability) that can be obtained by selecting optimal binary mixtures as working fluids of air-cooled ORC bottoming power plants of medium-capacity industrial gas turbines. Furthermore, two thermodynamic cycle configurations are analyzed, namely the simple recuperated cycle and the so-called split-cycle configurations. The benchmark case is a combined cycle power plant formed by an industrial gas turbine and an air-cooled recuperated ORC power unit with cyclopentane as the working fluid. The results of this study indicate that binary mixtures provide the designer with a wider choice of optimal working fluids, however, in the case of the recuperated-cycle configuration, no improvement in terms of combined cycle efficiency over the benchmark case can be achieved. The split-cycle configuration leads to an increase of combined cycle efficiency of the order of 1.5%, both in case of pure and blended working fluids. Furthermore, for this cycle configuration the use of Novec 649 as working fluid is advantageous because it is environmentally and operationally safe, and it does not involve any penalty in terms of combined cycle efficiency if compared to the benchmark case. Additionally, the use of this fluid would lead to a more compact turbine, as the corresponding thermodynamic cycle would determine a turbine volume flow ratio that is half of the value of the benchmark case and a specific enthalpy difference over the expansion that is one fifth.

@en

The aircraft Environmental Control System (ECS) is the primary consumer of non-propulsive power at cruise conditions, hence, its performance optimization is crucial for the reduction of specific fuel consumption. A novel integrated system design optimization method is presented: thermodynamic cycle, component sizing and working fluid are taken into account simultaneously. This method was applied to the ECS of large rotorcraft based on a Vapour Compression Cycle system electrically driven by a high-speed centrifugal compressor. Steady-state and lumped parameter system component models have been developed using the Modelica acausal modelling language. The optimization design framework consists of an in-house code, featuring a Python-Modelica interface. The study case refers to a critical operating condition: the helicopter is on the ground during a hot and humid day. The working fluid is R-134a. The multi-objective optimization targets the maximization of the system efficiency and the minimization of system weight. The results show that more efficient systems can be designed only with heavier components. The design feasibility of high-speed centrifugal compressors is demonstrated. The advantage of an integrated system design optimization framework for complex energy systems is proved, allowing for the analysis of the impact of both component design and working fluid on system performance.

@en

Compressible flows of fluids whose thermophysical properties are related by complex equations are quantitatively and can be qualitatively different from high-speed flows of ideal gases. Nonideal compressible fluid dynamics (NICFD) is concerned with these fluid flows, which are relevant in many processes and power and propulsion systems. Typically, NICFD effects occur if the fluid is an organic compound and its vapor state is close to the vapor–liquid critical point, at high-reduced temperature and pressure (even supercritical). Current design and analysis of devices operating in the nonideal compressible regime demand for validated simulation software, characterized in terms of uncertainty. Moreover, experiments are needed to further validate related theory. Experimental data are limited as generating and measuring these flows is challenging given their high pressure or temperature or both. In addition, flows of organic compounds can be flammable, can thermally decompose, and sealing may demand for special materials. Recently, more research has been devoted to the measurement of these flows using both intrusive and less intrusive techniques relying on optical access and lasers. The transparency and refractive properties of these dense vapors pose additional problems. The ORCHID (organic Rankine cycle hybrid integrated device) at the Aerospace Propulsion and Power Laboratory of Delft University of Technology is a closed-loop facility, used to generate a continuous nonideal supersonic flow of siloxane MM with the vapor at 4bar and 220 °C at the inlet of the test section. Within this work, we have employed particle image velocimetry for the first time to obtain the velocity field in a de Laval nozzle in such flows. Measured velocity fields (expanded uncertainty within 1.1% of the maximum velocity) have been compared with those resulting from a CFD simulation. The comparison between experimental and simulated data is satisfactory, with deviation ranging from 0.1 to 10 % from the throat to the outlet, respectively. This discrepancy is attributed to hardware limitations, which will be overcome in the future experiments. The feasibility of PIV with uncontrolled but fixed seeding density to measure high-speed vapors of organic vapors has been demonstrated, and future experimental campaigns will target flows for which nonideal effects are more pronounced, other paradigmatic configurations, and improvements to the measurement techniques.

@en

Waste heat recovery (WHR) from aero engines via compact organic Rankine cycle (ORC) units may increase the fuel efficiency of air transportation. Heat exchangers are arguably the key components of ORC systems for aeronautical applications and their design must be optimized to guarantee the best trade-off between fluid pressure drop, weight, and induced aircraft drag. At present, no heat exchanger design guidelines are available for waste heat recovery systems aboard aircraft. This study, thus, contributes to defining a proper design methodology for ORC systems of such applications. The chosen
test case is a supercritical ORC system with cyclopentane as the working fluid, which recovers waste heat from the auxiliary power unit of an aircraft. The exhaust gas temperature and mass flow rate of the power unit are known and kept constant in the analysis, and so are the ambient conditions, which define the cold sink of the ORC turbogenerator. Three design strategies targeting the minimum mass and maximum net power output of the ORC unit have been assessed. In the first one, the multi-objective optimization is performed by prescribing a priori the geometry and frontal area of the heat exchangers.
Thus, only the cycle parameters are optimized. The second method tackles, instead, the simultaneous optimization of the geometric parameters of the condenser and the cycle parameters. It was found that the integrated design allows for system mass reduction by 10 - 12% for a given ORC power output, highlighting the importance of performing the simultaneous optimization of the thermodynamic process and the heat exchanger geometry. Finally, the third method addresses the same optimal design problem by leveraging a reduced-order model of the condenser to predict the optimal design space of this component. The generated Pareto front obtained with this method is very similar to that found by optimizing simultaneously the complete condenser geometry and the cycle parameters. The mean deviation is about 2%. With just one heat exchanger surrogate model, the Pareto front was generated in one-fourth of the computational time. This is due to the lower number of optimization variables and the faster objective function evaluation.@en

The Environmental Control System (ECS) of passenger aircraft is the main consumer of non-propulsive power aboard. A computationally efficient and accurate thermal model of the fuselage is needed for future sustainable aircraft to address ECS preliminary sizing and control design, as the ECS should be re-designed to exploit possible synergies with other thermal management systems on board. Differently from previous works, the present aircraft thermal model is extensively documented and released open-source. Moreover, it is completely based on first principles and the acausal modeling paradigm. It results that the model is scalable, easily extendable, and allows for the estimation of the aircraft thermal loads given limited information about its configuration and flight mission. The predictive capabilities of the model have been assessed by comparing the thermodynamic state estimated at the pack discharge for three ECS operating points of an Airbus A320 with data provided by the manufacturer. The maximum deviation is limited to 2.4 K and 4.5 kPa. The validated thermal model has been used to compute the operating envelope of the A320 ECS, showing that the air supply requirements vary substantially with ambient conditions and flight phases. This calls for a multi-point design strategy when assessing novel ECS configurations.

@en

This paper presents a preliminary study about a combined-cycle engine based on a turboshaft engine and an organic-Rankine-cycle (ORC) bottoming unit to be used onboard an aircraft with a turboelectric propulsion system. The aim is to analyse whether benefits with respect to mission fuel consumption can be derived by employing such a combined-cycle
engine when compared to a simple-cycle turboshaft engine. For this purpose, a multidisciplinary optimization framework is developed, incorporating models for the engine, ORC system, ORC turbine, heat exchangers, and mission analysis. This framework is coupled with an optimizer to identify the optimal combined-cycle engine design for minimum mission fuel consumption. The results suggest that fuel savings of around 1.5% are possible with the optimized system if compared to the aircraft employing turboshaft engines. Heat exchanger volume is identified as the most constraining parameter when it comes to combined-cycle performance. The analysis of the results suggests as aspects which might lead to further improvements the evaluation of other ORC architectures, working fluids and heat exchanger topologies.@en

In evaporators, the distribution of the liquid and vapor phases among the channels is a convoluted problem, depending on a wide range of parameters. However, maldistribution causes important losses of performance. Due to their complexity, the accurate modeling of such two-phase flows is difficult to handle. Hence, experimental studies are still of great importance to help the understanding of maldistribution behaviors inside evaporators. Most of the experimental investigations of two-phase flow distribution are measuring the liquid and vapor quantities in the channels through a phase separation process, increasing the test duration and complexity. As a consequence, the number of parameters investigated is usually limited. Therefore, a new inline instrumentation method would allow for a more complete study by simplifying the measurement process. In the present work, an isothermal air/water mixture was used as fluid. The distribution of the two phases in eight channels of 10-mm I.D. connected to a simplified header was investigated. The inlet mass flow rates considered ranged from 0 to 0.025 kg/s for the water, and from 0 to 0.022 kg/s for the air. Consequently, qualities x up to 0.7 and void fractions ® up to 0.9 were reached. All the tests were carried at a pressure condition of 7 bar to reach a liquid to vapor density ratio similar to what is encountered for traditional refrigerant. Finally, to allow a continuous measurement process, the mass flow rates in each of the 10-mm I.D. channel were measured using a flowmeter calibrated on a separate line. Since no void fraction meter was coupled, a new iterative methodology, based on the Venturi pressure drops measurement solely, was developed and is proposed here. It proved to successfully predict the vapor and liquid phase flow rates in each channel.

@en

This work assessed the accuracy of the SU2 flow solver in predicting the isentropic expansion of Siloxane MM through the converging-diverging nozzle test section of the Organic Rankine Cycle Hybrid Integrated Device (ORCHID) [9]. The expansion is modeled using compressible Euler equations, and assuming adiabatic flow, while the fluid thermodynamic properties are estimated using the Peng-Robinson equation of state. The boundary conditions for the experiment and simulations correspond to a stagnation temperature and pressure of T¯0=253.7∘C and P¯0=18.36bar. At these inlet conditions the compressibility factor of the fluid is Z₀= 0.58. The back pressure was equal to P¯b=2.21bar. The Mach number along the centreline, and static pressure along the nozzle surface were used as the system response quantities for the validation exercise. The studied SU2 model provides valid predictions for Mach number and static pressure. The largest deviation observed in the Mach number comparison between the simulation and experiment is in the uniform flow region of the nozzle and is equal to E_Mach= 0.045. Regarding the pressure trend, the largest discrepancy occurs in the kernel region and is equal to E_pressure= 9 kPa. At the same time, the simulated Mach number and static pressure reach a maximum absolute uncertainty of ± 0.015 and of ± 20 kPa, respectively. For both quantities, these values are reached in the region close to the throat. All the uncertainties calculated for the simulated pressure profile were larger than those of the experiments. The static pressure is particularly sensitive to the geometrical uncertainties of the nozzle profile, especially inside the kernel region. A proper characterisation of the nozzle geometry was therefore required to perform a meaningful validation of the fluid dynamic solver. The developed infrastructure can be used in the future for the validation of SU2 in different operating conditions and flow cases.

@en

This paper describes an experiment conducted within the nozzle test section of the Organic Rankine Cycle Hybrid Integrated Device (ORCHID) aimed at providing accurate data for the validation of NICFD flow solvers [5]. A supersonic flow of the dense vapor siloxane MM established in the nozzle of the setup was characterized by means of the schlieren technique and by pressure taps along the nozzle profile. The nozzle inlet conditions corresponded to a stagnation temperature and pressure of T0=253∘C and P0=18.36bara. At these inlet conditions, the compressibility factor of the fluid is Z₀= 0.58. The nozzle backpressure was equal to Pb=2.2bara. The experimental data-set includes: 1) the average mid-plane local Mach number, which was derived from the schlieren images by estimating the angle of the Mach waves originating from the roughness of the upper and lower nozzle surfaces, 2) the angle of a shock wave generated by a 5^∘ wedge placed at the nozzle exit, also detectable in the schlieren images, and 3) the static pressure distribution along the flow expansion acquired with a Scanivalve DSA3218 pressure scanner device. The Mach number at the nozzle exit estimated based on the schlieren images is M= 1.95 ± 0.05, very close to the expected value of M= 2 according to the design conditions of the experiment. The static pressure measurements have a maximum absolute uncertainty amounting to ± 1.80 kPa in the initial stages of the expansion. This information was used to assess the capability of the open-source SU2 flow solver in evaluating the NICFD effects in a supersonic flow of MM when the fluid thermodynamic properties are modeled with a cubic equation of state. For this purpose, two-dimensional Euler simulations were carried out with SU2 for the operating conditions achieved in the experiment. The numerical results are in good agreement with the experimental data. The largest deviation between the simulation and experiment is observed in the nozzle uniform region, where two dips in the Mach number occur due to a slight local decrease in flow velocity owing to two weak shock waves. The shock wave generated by the wedge located at the nozzle outlet propagates with two different angles, namely, β_above= 37. 6^∘± 0.86, and β_below= 31. 6^∘± 0.64, due to the axial misalignment of the wedge with respect to the flow.

@en

This paper presents a preliminary study about a combined-cycle engine based on a turboshaft engine and an organic-Rankine-cycle (ORC) bottoming unit to be used onboard an aircraft with a turboelectric propulsion system. The aim is to analyse whether benefits with respect to mission fuel consumption can be derived by employing such a combined-cycle engine when compared to a simple-cycle turboshaft engine. For this purpose, a multidisciplinary optimization framework is developed, incorporating models for the engine, ORC system, ORC turbine, heat exchangers, and mission analysis. This framework is coupled with an optimizer to identify the optimal combined-cycle engine design for minimum mission fuel consumption. The results suggest that fuel savings of around 4% are possible with the optimized system if compared to the aircraft employing turboshaft engines. Heat exchanger volume is identified as the most constraining parameter when it comes to combined-cycle performance. The analysis of the results suggests as aspects which might lead to further improvements the evaluation of other ORC architectures, working fluids and heat exchanger topologies.@en

This paper documents a thermo-fluid-dynamic mean-line model for the preliminary design of multistage axial turbines with blade cooling applicable to supercritical CO₂ turbines. Given the working fluid and coolant inlet thermodynamic conditions, blade geometry, number of stages and load criterion, the model computes the stage-by-stage design along with the cooling requirement and ultimately provides an estimate of turbine efficiency via a semi-empirical loss model. Different cooling modes are available and can be selected by the user (stand-alone or combination): convective cooling, film cooling, and thermal barrier coating. The model is applied to attain the preliminary aero-thermal design of the 600 MW cooled axial supercritical CO₂ turbine of the Allam cycle. Results show that a load coefficient varying from 3 to 1 throughout the machine, and a reaction degree ranging from 0.1 to 0.5 lead to the maximum total-to-static turbine efficiency of about 85%. Consequently, as opposed to uncooled CO₂ turbines, a repeated stage configuration is an unsuited design choice for cooled sCO₂ machines. Moreover, the study highlights that film cooling is considerably less effective compared to conventional gas turbines, while increasing the number of stages from 5 to 6 and adopting higher rotational speeds leads to an increased efficiency.

@en

The use of mixtures in place of pure fluids in Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) power plants is proposed as a possible improvement in terms of efficiency, environmental benefit and safety of the system. In particular, zeotropic mixtures exhibit a temperature variation (or glide) during phase change, because the components have different boiling points. This temperature glide improves the temperature profile matching in the heat exchangers and could in turn increase the overall thermoeconomic efficiency of the power plant, especially if it is air cooled. Even though the solution is theoretically beneficial, its practical feasibility has still to be proven. To this scope, we developed an optimization algorithm that determines the optimal mixture composition and thermodynamic parameters of the cycle and performs the preliminary design of the air cooler of the power plant. As initial case study we chose a heat recovery application and ran single objective optimizations to select the binary mixture that maximizes the power plants thermodynamic efficiency. Initial results show that, when the ratio between the turbine and fan power is high and the maximum temperature is constrained by fluid stability considerations, mixtures with low or no glide are the most efficient. The optimization procedure will eventually be extended to include also the economic aspect and additional studies will be performed for the geothermal application, where mixtures are expected to be much more beneficial due to the lower temperature of the heat source. @en

This paper reports one of the initial NICFD experiments in the nozzle test section of the ORCHID aimed at providing accurate data for the validation of flow solvers, albeit, at this stage of the research, the focus is limited to inviscid phenomena. Notably, a series of schlieren photographs displaying Mach waves in the supersonic flow of the dense vapor of siloxane MM were obtained and are documented here for the commissioning experiment, namely, for inlet conditions corresponding to a stagnation temperature and pressure of T0=252∘C and P0=18.4bara. At these inlet conditions the compressibility factor of the fluid is Z₀= 0.58. The digital processing of the schlieren images allowed to estimate multiple angles formed by the Mach waves stemming from the upper and lower nozzle surfaces because of the infinitesimal density perturbations generated by the, albeit small, roughness of the metal surfaces. These values are related to the local Mach number by a simple geometric relation. Moreover, the total expanded uncertainty in the Mach number was computed. This information together with the estimate of the average Mach number was used for a first assessment of the capability of evaluating NICFD effects occurring in a dense organic vapor flow of MM by comparison with the results of CFD simulations. The outcome of the comparison was satisfactory. It can thus be inferred that the nozzle test section has been commissioned and it is ready for experimental campaigns in which its full potential in terms of measurements accuracy, repeatability, and operational flexibility will be exploited.

@en

This paper documents a numerical study on entropy generation in zero-pressure gradient, laminar boundary layers of adiabatic non-ideal compressible fluid flows. The entropy generation is expressed in terms of dissipation coefficient $$C:\mathrm {d}$$ and its dependency on free-stream Mach number, fluid molecular complexity, and flow non-ideality is investigated systematically by means of a boundary layer code extended to treat fluids modeled with arbitrary equations of state. The results of the study show that the trend of dissipation coefficient follows that of an incompressible flow for complex fluid molecules like siloxanes in all thermodynamic and flow conditions. For simpler fluids like CO$$:2$$ the trend becomes inversely proportional to the free-stream Mach number and the $$C:\mathrm {d}$$ value can significantly reduce in the non-ideal flow regime, where strong thermo-physical property gradients occur near the wall.

@en

The electric hybridization of heavy-duty road vehicles is a promising alternative to reduce the environmental impact of freight and passengers transportation. Employing a micro gas turbine as a prime mover offers several advantages: high power density, fuel flexibility, ultra-low emissions (without the need of exhaust after-treatment), low vibrations and noise, simplicity and lower maintenance cost. State-of-the-art micro gas turbines feature an efficiency of 30%, which can be increased to 40% by employing a mini organic Rankine cycle system as a bottoming power plant. Such a combined-cycle powertrain could achieve considerably higher efficiency with next-gen micro gas turbines and mini ORC systems, especially with an R&D push of the automotive sector. This paper presents the analysis of a hybrid electric heavy-duty vehicle with a prime mover based on this concept. The assessment was performed in two steps: (i) preliminary design of the combined cycle power plant, and (ii) estimation of the vehicle fuel economy and of the emissions over a representative driving cycle. The best combined cycle system stemming from the design exercise features an estimated peak efficiency of 44%, and a nominal power output of about 150 kW. This corresponds to the power demand at cruise condition of a long-haul truck (weight approx. 36 ton). A series configuration with Lithium-Ion batteries was selected for the hybrid powertrain, for it decouples the prime mover dynamics from the power demand. The benchmark is a vehicle featuring a next generation diesel engine, with a peak efficiency equal to 50%. The results show that the fuel economy can be largely improved by increasing the size of the battery in the hybrid powertrain. Furthermore, employing natural gas in the prime mover of the hybrid vehicle leads to ultra-low emissions that are well below the limits set by European and north American regulations, without the need of exhaust gas aftertreatment. Additionally, the CO2 emissions of the hybrid powertrain are considerably lower than that of the benchmark. The work documented here thus demonstrates the potential of this hybrid powertrain concept, especially in terms of exhaust emissions, as a promising transition technology towards the full electrification of the powertrain. @en

The realization of commercial mini organic Rankine cycle (ORC) power systems (tens of kW of power output) is currently pursued by means of various research and development activities. The application driving most of the efforts is the waste heat recovery from long-haul truck engines. Obtaining an efficient mini radial inflow turbine, arguably the most suitable type of expander for this application, is particularly challenging, given the small mass flow rate, and the occurrence of nonideal compressible fluid dynamic effects in the stator. Available design methods are currently based on guidelines and loss models developed mainly for turbochargers. The preliminary geometry is subsequently adapted by means of computational fluid-dynamic calculations with codes that are not validated in case of nonideal compressible flows of organic fluids. An experimental 10 kW mini-ORC radial inflow turbine will be realized and tested in the Propulsion and Power Laboratory of the Delft University of Technology, with the aim of providing measurement datasets for the validation of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tools and the calibration of empirical loss models. The fluid dynamic design and characterization of this machine is reported here. Notably, the turbine is designed using a meanline model in which fluid-dynamic losses are estimated using semi-empirical correlations for conventional radial turbines. The resulting impeller geometry is then optimized using steady-state three-dimensional computational fluid dynamic models and surrogate-based optimization. Finally, a loss breakdown is performed and the results are compared against those obtained by three-dimensional unsteady fluid-dynamic calculations. The outcomes of the study indicate that the optimal layout of mini-ORC turbines significantly differs from that of radial-inflow turbines (RIT) utilized in more traditional applications, confirming the need for experimental campaigns to support the conception of new design practices.

@en

The conventional design of organic Rankine cycle (ORC) power systems starts with the selection of the working fluid and the subsequent optimization of the corresponding thermodynamic cycle. More recently, systematic methods have been proposed integrating the selection of the working fluid into the optimization of the thermodynamic cycle. However, in both cases, the turbine is designed subsequently. This procedure can lead to a suboptimal design, especially in the case of mini- and small-scale ORC systems, since the preselected combination of working fluid and operating conditions may lead to infeasible turbine designs. The resulting iterative design procedure may end in conservative solutions after multiple trial-and-error attempts due to the strong interdependence of the many design variables and constraints involved. In this work, we therefore present a new design and optimization method integrating working fluid selection, thermodynamic cycle design, and preliminary turbine design. To this purpose, our recent 1-stage continuous-molecular targeting (CoMT)-computer-aided molecular design (CAMD) method for the integrated design of the ORC process and working fluid is expanded by a turbine meanline design procedure. Thereby, the search space of the optimization is bounded to regions where the design of the turbine is feasible. The resulting method has been tested for the design of a small-scale high-temperature ORC unit adopting a radial-inflow turbo-expander. The results confirm the potential of the proposed method over the conventional iterative design practice for the design of small-scale ORC turbogenerators.

@en

By means of this corrigendum, the authors would like to include relevant information regarding the validation of the meanline turbine model employed in the original article. The improvement regarding the validation of the model was made possible thanks to the contribution of Prof. Jürg Schiffmann. The additional results documented here provide more confidence on the reliability of the model when it applied to mini-ORC turbines. Therefore, we kindly ask the Editor to add his name to the authors list. The following paragraph extends the one that discusses the meanline validation located in Section 2. The turbine preliminary design is performed by means of a meanline code, which is based on the loss models listed in Ref. [1]. These models have been developed for conventional turbomachinery operating with fluids in the ideal gas state, featuring subsonic flows and large Reynolds numbers. The meanline code has been validated with the results of literature test cases presenting these characteristics [2]. It has been also compared against an experimentally validated turbine model for mORC machines operating in the subsonic regime [3]. Table 1 shows the information of the machine geometry for which results of the two codes were compared, while Fig. 1 presents the meridional channel of the turbine. Table 2 shows the corresponding operating conditions. The results of the total-to-static efficiency computation are presented in Fig. 2. It can be observed that the efficiency trend obtained with zTurbo is similar to that computed with the validated EPFL code. The comparison between the two models suggests a deviation lower than 2.5% for all the tested operating conditions. This deviation occurs because each model uses a different set of loss correlations. These correlations are described in Refs. [1,3].

@en