Circular Image

Amineh Ghorbani

info

Please Note

45 records found

The large-scale development of offshore wind is a complex socio-technical challenge in which technological performance, economic viability, government policy, energy markets, and the decisions of multiple actors are strongly interconnected. Developers and investors must make long-term design, bidding, and investment decisions under considerable uncertainty. Technical modelling uncertainty can therefore propagate beyond engineering calculations into financial assessments, tender strategies, and ultimately the viability of offshore wind projects. Improving the information available to decision-makers is consequently important for individual projects and the wider transition towards a low-carbon electricity system.

Wake prediction represents one important source of uncertainty. Wind turbines reduce downstream wind speeds, affecting neighbouring turbines and the expected energy yield of a wind farm. Engineering wake models such as Jensen are computationally efficient but rely on simplifying assumptions, while high-fidelity Large Eddy Simulations (LES) provide more detailed representations of wake behaviour at much greater computational cost. This creates a trade-off between prediction accuracy and computational effort, particularly when many layouts or scenarios must be evaluated.

This thesis investigates whether a Graph Neural Network (GNN) trained on high-fidelity LES data can improve offshore wind-farm wake predictions while maintaining computational efficiency compared with traditional engineering wake models. A turbine-interaction GNN was developed in which turbines are represented as nodes and potential wake interactions as directed edges. Through message passing, the model learns how upstream turbines influence downstream wind-speed deficits. The architecture was first verified using synthetic Jensen data and subsequently evaluated using the WINS50 LES dataset. The experiments investigated heterogeneous inflow information, turbulence intensity, atmospheric-stability indicators, graph construction, and alternative message-passing architectures. Finally, a multi-farm GNN was trained on 25 wind farms and evaluated on the unseen future_052 layout, using Jensen/NOJ as the principal engineering-model baseline.

The experiments demonstrate that the GNN can successfully learn turbine–turbine wake relationships. Additional model information and complexity did not automatically improve prediction accuracy. Local wind speed provided useful information about heterogeneous conditions, while local wind direction offered limited additional benefit. Turbulence intensity generally improved performance, and exploratory experiments indicated that atmospheric-stability information may provide further predictive value. Wider interaction corridors improved predictions, whereas full connectivity offered only a small additional improvement at substantially greater computational cost. An attention-based architecture also did not outperform the edge-conditioned NNConv model, indicating that a relatively simple, physically informed graph representation can efficiently capture relevant wake interactions.

The strongest result was obtained in the cross-farm experiment. When trained on 25 wind farms and evaluated on the excluded future_052 layout, the GNN achieved a mean absolute error of 0.7888 m/s, compared with 1.0859 m/s for Jensen, representing an approximately 27% reduction in prediction error. The GNN also exhibited virtually no mean prediction bias. Including graph construction, evaluation of the complete test set was approximately 4.5 times faster than the Jensen implementation. These results demonstrate that wake relationships learned from computationally expensive LES simulations can be transferred to an unseen wind-farm layout while retaining computational efficiency.

An illustrative valuation case translated predicted wind speeds into annual energy production (AEP) and discounted lifetime revenues. For the considered wind farm, the LES reference resulted in an AEP of approximately 5318 GWh. The GNN overestimated AEP by approximately 0.6%, corresponding to a discounted lifetime revenue error of approximately EUR 22.8 million under the case-study assumptions. The Jensen model produced a substantially larger energy-production and revenue error. Although this was not a complete financial valuation, it demonstrated how technical modelling errors can propagate into economically significant differences in project assessment.

Overall, LES-trained turbine-interaction GNNs provide a promising link between high-fidelity physical simulation and the computational efficiency required for repeated wind-farm assessment. Improved prediction accuracy and faster evaluation could help developers and investors compare layouts, expected revenues, investment alternatives, and tender strategies more reliably, while enabling more scenarios to be assessed under uncertainty. With further validation, these models could provide a more reliable technical basis for wind-farm design and investment decisions, supporting the large-scale development of offshore wind capacity. ...

Simulating the Impact of Risk Rating 2.0 on the Distribution of Dynamic Flood Risk in Houston, Texas

Master thesis (2026) - P. Mueller, S. Balakrishnan, Amineh Ghorbani, David Bresch, Lukas Riedel
Climate change is increasing coastal flood risk by synchronizing once-independent flood losses into correlated, systemic events. Under this pressure, the U.S. National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) has accumulated a structural deficit exceeding twenty billion dollars. In response, FEMA is introducing Risk Rating 2.0 (RR2), the largest pricing reform in the program’s history. RR2 replaces zone-based premiums with property-level actuarial pricing, turning insurance premiums into a property-level risk signal. By elevating their homes, households can reduce both flood risk and insurance premiums, potentially creating a feedback loop between adaptation and affordability. However, adaptation requires substantial upfront investment. This thesis therefore asks: what is the long-term impact of Risk Rating 2.0 on the distribution of dynamic flood risk in Houston, Texas?

To address this question, a coupled human–flood agent-based model (ABM) was developed for the Houston–Galveston Bay area, representing 43,294 residential properties over a 30-year period. The model replicates both the legacy NFIP premium methodology and the RR2 pricing methodology as paired treatment and control scenarios, exposing identical households to identical flood hazards so that differences are attributable solely to the pricing regime. Household decisions on home elevation and insurance coverage are modelled using cumulative prospect theory under evolving risk perception and budget constraints. The analysis evaluates physical exposure, financial exposure, and adaptive capacity following the IPCC AR6 risk framework to examine the premium–adaptation–risk feedback mechanism introduced by RR2.

The results show that the RR2 risk signal functions as intended in encouraging adaptation. Households increasingly substitute physical risk reduction for insurance coverage, resulting in substantially higher home elevations but lower insurance penetration. Expected annual flood damage decreases modestly, while the reduction in insurance coverage increases uninsured structural losses and widens the protection gap. Although flood risk declines across most census tracts, no evidence is found for the emergence of local risk hotspots. Instead, the aggregate results conceal an increasingly unequal distribution of risk. The risk signal is most effective for middle-income households with relatively high flood exposure and lower property values, which can afford adaptation and benefit most from premium reductions. Lower-income households are often unable to finance elevation measures, while wealthier households face relatively weak incentives to substitute insurance with adaptation. As a result, both physical and financial risk shift toward more vulnerable households. Under a changing climate, this redistribution becomes stronger because the system no longer reaches a stable equilibrium. Consequently, RR2 not only responds to climate risk but also becomes a source of social vulnerability by transferring risk from the insurance pool to individual households.

Methodologically, this thesis presents the first coupled human–flood ABM to incorporate FEMA’s complete RR2 pricing methodology together with an endogenous premium–adaptation–risk feedback loop. The model combines empirically informed parcel-level data with heterogeneous household behaviour and cumulative prospect theory and is fully documented and open sourced for future research.

The findings have important policy implications. Reporting expected annual damage alone conceals who ultimately bears flood losses and therefore masks the widening protection gap. Rather than subsidizing insurance premiums, policy should prioritize means-tested support for home elevation, enabling vulnerable households to benefit from the adaptation pathway created by RR2. Although the model does not account for household relocation, changing behavioural preferences, or fully dynamic climate projections, it provides valuable ex-ante insight into the long-term distributional consequences of risk-based flood insurance. More broadly, the results are relevant beyond the United States, as many countries are considering similar risk-based insurance systems under increasing climate risk. ...

An interdisciplinary exploration of philosophical issues

Doctoral thesis (2026) - A. Melnyk, I.R. van de Poel, N. Doorn, Amineh Ghorbani
This dissertation examines how values change in the context of climate change and energy transitions. It departs from the observation that energy transitions are not only technological or economic transformations, but also moral and political processes in which values are continuously interplay. While values are frequently invoked in debates on sustainability, they are often treated as fixed or external to socio-technical change. This dissertation instead approaches value change as a dynamic, relational phenomenon that emerges through interactions between people, technologies, institutions, and the environment. The central aim is to develop a philosophically grounded account of value change that captures its multilevel and context-dependent character, while also demonstrating how such change can be studied philosophically, empirically, and computationally. To do so, the dissertation combines philosophical analysis with insights from social science and computational modelling across a set of interconnected studies.

Part I investigates the role of values in energy transitions, focusing on community energy initiatives. Drawing on community energy scholarship and empirical materials, it shows that value change can take multiple forms: as a bottom-up process emerging from resistance to incumbent systems, as a policy objective embedded in governance frameworks, and as an outcome of socio-technical and ecological interactions. A key insight is that values are plural and relational, meaning that ethical dilemmas arise not only between competing values but also within them, shaped by specific institutional, technological, and local contexts.

Part II develops a philosophical account of value change in dialogue with climate ethics and the philosophy of technology. Engaging with philosophical perspectives on value conflict, it challenges the view that value change necessarily leads to irresolvable tensions. Instead, it proposes an interpretive account in which values are continuously redefined in response to new moral challenges. Within this framework, moral expansion is introduced as one mechanism of value change, understood as the extension of moral concern to new domains, including future generations, non-human entities, and the environment. This process is neither linear nor inevitable, but contingent, uneven, and shaped by technological, environmental, material, and institutional conditions.

Part III turns to methodology, exploring how value change can be studied using computational social science, in particular, agent-based modelling. Here, models are treated as exploratory instruments that make assumptions about values explicit and allow the implications of different value configurations to be examined across multiple levels of analysis. Through an explorative model of moral expansion, the dissertation demonstrates how computational approaches can complement philosophical inquiry by enabling systematic reflection on dynamic moral processes.

The dissertation makes three main contributions. First, it conceptualises value change as a relational and multilevel process embedded in socio-technical and environmental systems. Second, it develops an interpretive account of value change that moves beyond views of value conflict as inherently irreconcilable. Drawing on and critically engaging with pluralist and interpretivist traditions, in particular the work of Ronald Dworkin and Isaiah Berlin, it shows how values are not only in tension but also subject to reinterpretation over time. This account provides an approach to understanding ethical dilemmas in energy transitions as evolving, situated processes shaped by institutional, technological, environmental, and material conditions, rather than as fixed or intractable conflicts. Third, it advances a methodological approach for studying value change by integrating philosophical analysis with computational social science. In particular, it introduces moral expansion as a mechanism for understanding how values evolve in response to new challenges and demonstrates how agent-based models can serve as exploratory tools to make value assumptions explicit and examine their implications across levels of analysis, thereby enabling systematic reflection on dynamic moral processes. ...

A Multi-Dimensional Greenwashing Risk Assessment Tool Integrating Environmental Performance Data with NLP Communication Analysis

Clean energy spending needs to reach $4.5 trillion per year by 2030 to maintain a realistic chance of limiting global warming, yet current investment represents just 37% of what is needed for net zero by 2050. This and other energy transition requirements put enormous pressure on electric utilities to transform their business models while maintaining energy security and attracting investment, creating conditions ripe for potential greenwashing as companies might oversell environmental progress or engage in misleading communication strategies to stay competitive. Three fundamental gaps have limited systematic greenwashing detection: the separation between performance and communication analysis, single-dimensional communication measurement, and the lack of sector-specific methods.
This research addresses the question: What greenwashing risk assessment tool can be developed for European electric utility companies based on environmental performance metrics and multi-dimensional communication analysis? This Master thesis research project developed and tested the first systematic Greenwashing Risk Assessment Tool (GRAT), designed specifically for electric utilities but adaptable to other sectors through modified inputs, weights, and terminology. The GRAT bridges theoretical gaps by integrating quantitative performance measurement with multi-dimensional communication analysis. Constrained ensemble methodology is used to handle weight uncertainty for both performance scoring and greenwashing risk. The greenwashing risk is measured by five different dimensions: performance-communication gap, substantiation weakness, language vagueness, temporal orientation, and reporting consistency.
The GRAT follows a clear three-step process that can be understood and adapted without advanced programming skills. Users gather environmental data from several sources: third-party verified information like Refinitiv Eikon, self-reported metrics like CDP, and English sustainability reports. Once this data is collected, the tool automatically handles performance scoring, runs communication analysis through rule-based NLP methods, and produces integrated risk assessments. Rather than using completely arbitrary weights, the constrained ensemble approach tests thousands of valid weight combinations within available theoretical boundaries.
The tool was tested on 14 European electric utility companies during 2021-2022. Among these companies, the analysis found significant environmental performance differences. Scores ranged from 15.0 to 95.0 points, with year-over-year changes spanning from -35.1 to +63.0 points. Companies used different communication strategies that did not align with their performance scores. Only 36% showed temporal changes where performance and communication moved in the same direction, revealing a pattern where communication strategies often work independently from actual environmental achievements. When combining both aspects including the other communication quality dimensions, risk scores fell between 16.5 and 81.3.
The validation approach is methodologically sound, though statistical limitations arise from the small sample size. External validation provides indicative evidence that the GRAT may distinguish between companies with documented greenwashing accusations and those with clean records, but results could represent random phenomena between 2021-2022. The GRAT enables regulators to screen companies requiring investigation rather than providing conclusive evidence of greenwashing. This helps investors assess risk patterns in sustainability portfolios and offers researchers a tool adaptable to other sectors. ...

Benefits, Challenges, and Opportunities

Master thesis (2025) - L.A. Gallois, Stefano Cucurachi, Amineh Ghorbani
Education plays a central role in enabling sustainable societies, as highlighted by the emergence of Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) following the 1992 UN Conference on Environment and Development. Within higher education, sustainability-focused programs, referred to in this study as sustainability higher education (SHE), aim to equip students with key competencies needed to address complex sustainability challenges, often requiring transformative and interdisciplinary pedagogical approaches. In this context, art-based teaching (ABT) has gained attention as a method that can enhance learning by encouraging creativity, critical thinking, emotional processing, and collaboration, while addressing diverse sustainability topics. Industrial Ecology (IE) programs provide a pertinent case study for exploring ABT integration, given their interdisciplinary approach to complex environmental challenges and the current lack of research on ABT in this domain. Despite growing interest, knowledge gaps remain regarding the contextual factors influencing ABT integration, its benefits and challenges, and how these practices contribute to sustainability key competencies. This study addresses these gaps by combining through a systematic literature review of 11 peer-reviewed articles on SHE and 14 interviews with educators and students from four Northern European IE programs, aiming to provide educators with evidence to support the transformative potential of ABT in sustainability higher education.
The study first investigated how and why ABT practices are incorporated in SHE. Analysis revealed a wide range of practices across disciplines, highlighting the influence of contextual factors such as group size, teaching team expertise, and co-teaching with artists. Active student participation was common and enhanced engagement and ownership, while non-participatory approaches also provided value. Purposes of ABT interventions such as mapping systems, expressing emotions, and generating ideas, aligned with literature on higher education goals while reflecting research-oriented objectives, particularly from the empirical data in IE.
The study then identified 26 potential benefits and 15 challenges of ABT integration. Benefits demonstrated the broad potential of ABT for sustainability education, whereas challenges highlighted pedagogical and implementation barriers and raised questions about cultural and educational paradigms in Western higher education.
Linking these benefits to the Brundiers et al. (2021) sustainability key competencies framework confirmed trends observed by Heras (2022): ABT particularly supports intrapersonal, interpersonal, and normative competencies. Additionally, this study highlighted the potential for ABT to contribute to futures-thinking and systems-thinking competencies, especially as reported by educators in IE. No clear evidence was found regarding the contribution of ABT to implementation competencies.
Future research could broaden the scope by including participants from diverse disciplinary, cultural, and educational contexts, particularly non-Western or Indigenous traditions where art is central to knowledge transmission. Long-term impacts of ABT on student engagement, behavior, and professional practice should be investigated, along with institutional factors such as curriculum design, assessment systems, and educator training that could support the integration of art in higher education. ...

Analysing Lobbying-related Greenwashing in the Netherlands

Master thesis (2025) - L.L. Koole, Amineh Ghorbani, N. Goyal
This thesis explores the alignment between corporate climate commitments and climate lobbying behaviour among Dutch companies, by focusing on identifying lobbying-related greenwashing. In times where companies are seen as key players in combating the climate crises (European Commission, 2023), it is crucial that corporate climate lobby is aligned with their companies’ green commitments. Climate lobbying can significantly affect regulatory outcomes, so lobbying in favour of more stringent climate legislation would positively impact climate-related regulatory outcomes (Errichiello et al., 2025).
To examine this underexplored issue of lobby-related greenwashing, the research develops and applies a qualitative framework. This framework expands the framework of Nemes et al. (2022) and existing literature. Six categories of potentially misleading lobbying behaviour are included: (1) Direct lobbying against climate policy, (2) Affiliations with obstructive organisations, (3) Use of astroturf lobbying, (4) Symbolic communication through voluntary initiatives, (5) Undisclosed policy influence (revolving doors) and (6) Undisclosed influence in standards-setting.
The framework was applied through qualitative content analysis to six Dutch companies from different industries. These case studies were constructed using 2022 data from CDP disclosures, LobbyMap, the EU Transparency Register, corporate annual reports, and grey literature.
The study finds that the framework effectively captures a wide range of lobby-related greenwashing behaviours. Dutch companies in the sample were all greenwashing ranging from a moderate to a very high degree. Particularly indirect lobbying emerged as a common form of greenwashing, related to affiliation in trade associations and involvement in voluntary initiatives. Thus, while many companies publicly commit to supporting the Paris Agreement, their political actions often fail to reflect these commitments.
The framework can help scrutinise companies’ lobby behaviour, also beyond this research. The empirical outcomes are a first step towards an understanding of lobbying-related greenwashing in the Dutch context. Practically, they urge companies to align their indirect lobby strategies with their climate commitments. Without such alignment, their contribution to halting climate change remains severely limited.
Future research could build on the developed framework and findings. For example, by validating the framework and its categories through expert and company interviews, expanding case studies to cover more sectors and geographies, and refining the scoring system to incorporate weighting and greater nuance in assessing the degree of misalignment.
...
Master thesis (2024) - E. ATES, Z. Lukszo, Amineh Ghorbani, R.J. van t' Veer, Iman Pishbin, Edward Droste, Tayebeh Solatpour
Hydrogen is becoming increasingly integral to global energy transition strategies, especially in sectors difficult to electrify. In the Netherlands, industrial clusters are expected to be key centers for sustainable hydrogen supply and demand. However, smaller industries outside the main clusters (Cluster 6) face significant challenges due to their distance from major demand points and the complexities of integrating hydrogen into their operations. They struggle with the high initial investment costs for on-site hydrogen generation, limited access to decarbonization subsidies, and the technical challenges posed by a congested electricity grid. The lower priority given to these regions in the hydrogen roll-out plan exacerbates the uncertainty and hesitancy among Cluster 6 industries, threatening the efficient development of regional hydrogen infrastructure and creating a risk of underutilization. The research employs a modeling approach and agent-based simulation to analyze the potential for collective action to overcome technical, economic, and institutional limitations, facilitating hydrogen production and consumption among smaller, dispersed industries. This approach allows for comparative analysis of emergent system behavior under different organizing principles, agent interactions, and government policy interventions. The simulation results highlight that collective investment is key to successful hydrogen transitions, with unified strategies leading to quicker and more effective outcomes. When driven by individual efforts instead of collective action, transitions tend to face delays and result with less sector inclusion. In regions with more hydrogen-dependent companies, contribution of collective action grows exponentially, with primary off-takers initiating the shift. However, relaxing subsidy criteria in such regional settings can weaken regional cooperation and slow progress. Therefore, designing region-specific policies that promote collaboration and encouraging communication and inclusiveness among companies can help achieve a smoother and more unified regional shift to hydrogen. Future research should address the limitations of the current study by incorporating more detailed cost-benefit analyses, exploring alternative hydrogen supply and transportation methods, and considering a broader range of factors influencing industrial decisions on hydrogen adoption. ...

A Standardised Approach to Institutional Analysis Using Institutional Grammar

In the field of Institutional Analysis (IA), institutions describe the emergent rules that govern human behaviour and interaction. There are two key types: formal rules such as laws and policies, and informal rules such as norms and shared strategies. Evaluating the effectiveness of existing policies and developing new policies often requires a thorough understanding of informal rules. Traditional methods for identifying informal rules are predominantly qualitative, labour-intensive, and prone to bias, typically limited by small sample sizes. This thesis addresses the gap in standardised, quantitative approaches by developing a novel method to extract informal rules and social structures from survey data: Survey Informal Rule Extraction (SIRE).

The SIRE method involves preprocessing survey data, training decision trees to classify behaviours, extracting Institutional Grammar (IG) components, and generating structured Attribute, Deontic, Aim, Condition, Or else (ADICO) statements. The design process involves an iterative approach with three key steps: 1) exploring and comparing existing survey data from an institutional grammar lens, 2) evaluating different types of questions and identifying relationships in the data, and 3) testing various methods to analyse response data and convert questions into ADICO statements. These steps led to a systematic approach to understanding how informal rules shape human behaviour, supporting evidence-based policy design.

The effectiveness of SIRE is validated through three applications to datasets from the European Social Survey (ESS) and SCALAR. The first validation compares SIRE results with literature findings on household climate change adaptation, showing logical and comparable outcomes. The second validation demonstrates the method's utility in policy analysis, examining factors influencing the adoption of structural flood protection measures. The third validation showcased the method's potential as a strategic analytics tool for political parties, identifying conditions that increase the likelihood of voting for specific parties. The results demonstrate that the SIRE method has the potential to provide a clear representation of institutional rules, offering valuable insights for institutional and policy analysts.

While this thesis presents a novel method for extracting informal rules from survey data, limitations include potential generalizability issues due to the focused validation on specific datasets (SCALAR and ESS), AI-related inconsistencies in text processing, and methodological constraints such as the current inability to directly address open-ended questions or identify deontic components. Future work should focus on further validation across diverse contexts, integration with other analytical frameworks, and method automation. Improvements in data encoding, condition scope, and rule extraction could enhance the SIRE method's utility in policy development and behavioural analysis, addressing current limitations and expanding its applicability.
...

Application of the Institutional Analysis Approach to Assessing Alignment with Climate Justice

As climate change impacts rapidly escalate, ensuring the just adaptation of vulnerable communities has become a critical challenge. However, procedural justice—a key pillar of climate justice that focuses on the fairness of policies from a systemic standpoint—remains underexplored. Policy practitioners currently lack the tools to assess whether a policy can meaningfully engage affected groups. This research presents a novel approach to evaluating the procedural justice of climate change adaptation policies ex-ante, before their implementation.

While the impact of institutional structures on the adaptive capacity of systems is well-established, the direct relationship between these structures and the procedural justice of adaptive interventions has not been systematically studied. This research addresses this gap by applying the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework and incorporating Institutional Network Analysis to assess the procedural justice of climate adaptation interventions.

The research also demonstrates how Large Language Models support the automation of policy analysis tasks, and may be used to significantly improve the scale and timeliness of policy analysis research.

In this research we identify 4 values critical to procedurally just climate change adaptation policy institutions – namely Voice, Transparency, Accountability and Correctability. We operationalise these values in terms of institutional networks, and develop an empirical method for their identification. The work features a tool to automate extraction of policy statements from documents and features an annotation accuracy of 0.67.

Using this methodology, an empirical case of climate change policy ­— the expansion of Water and Wastewater Systems in Chennai — is investigated. The analysis shows that the institutional environment is severely lacking in procedural justice elements and that policy statements relevant to procedurally justice lack specificity. ...

An agent-based modelling approach

Master thesis (2023) - C. Theodorou, Amineh Ghorbani, L. Scholten
: There has been a growing number of companies that join, commit and set targets to the Science-Based Targets initiative in recent years. This thesis explores how factors which were found in previous studies to influence the companies’ decision to join SBTi or climate action in general, interact dynamically. Using an agent-based model, the companies’ interactions, the SBTi strategies and external factors will be examined in the temporal dimension in order to shed light on what is the projected uptake of SBTi. ...
In my thesis I was studying the interrelation between network topology and dynamics and the emergence and evolution of institutions for the governance of CPR. This research was intended to shed some light on what is the role of networks in formation of endogenous institutions and the possible insights for policy makers and users of CPR. To answer my research question, I utilized the agent-based institutional model and enhanced it by adding three dimensions of social networks and connecting them through various mechanisms to other parts of the model trying to capture the complexity of SESs. Therefore, through the combination of ABM and approaches from SNA I conducted a series of simulations that were imitating co-evolution of endogenous institutions and network topology. Through variation of input and output parameters the patterns were derived from the model and thoroughly analyzed. Notably, they suggest a positive relationship between the degree of network fragmentation and the stability of institutional structures within these communities. This implies that more fragmented social networks tend to exhibit greater stability in their institutional arrangements. Furthermore, the research reveals the presence of negative feedback mechanisms influencing network-dependent rewiring probabilities and positive feedback mechanisms governing homophily-based rewiring probabilities. These findings underscore the complexity of CPR governance, where network structures, institutional dynamics, and personal strategies interact in intricate ways. The results of this analysis were utilized to provide policy recommendations for regulation of CPRs. Mainly these recommendations evolve around: (i) identification and connection of fragments within social networks; (ii) analysis of the details of agents resource consumption, (iiI) identification of potential strategy options and (iv) enhancement of the processes that drive creation of gear- (or other attribute-) based connections. Overall, the research has the potential to inform the development of more effective and sustainable approaches to the governance of CPRs. ...
Master thesis (2023) - J.S. van Paassen, Amineh Ghorbani, N. Goyal
Situation
The constant increase in global temperatures is becoming more and more concerning for the future of our planet. The health of the planet is crucial for our existence and for the health of humanity, which is why we need to maintain and care for our environment. The pharmaceutical sector contributes to a lot of greenhouse gas emissions, and the total amount of emissions even exceeds that of the automotive industry. Pharmaceutical companies’ main goal is to improve human health, and therefore, contributing to a healthy environment is also crucial. Pharmaceutical companies have set ambitious climate goals that will need a lot of attention if they are to be fulfilled. More and more collective action initiatives are taking form, such as Energize and projects like Together for Sustainability (TfS). While a lot of progress is being made, collective efforts need to improve, and climate challenges need to be tackled collectively. Johnson & Johnson, as one of the largest pharmaceutical companies in the world, has committed to the SBTi targets and set ambitious goals for itself. They put a lot of emphasis on sustainability and aim to reach their targets across all its 250 subsidiary companies that are spread out over 60 countries.

Problem identification
As the climate impact of the pharmaceutical sector seems to be significantly large, it is important to understand how the climate targets of this sector can be fulfilled. Johnson & Johnson aims to source 100% of their electricity needs from renewable sources by 2025, achieve carbon neutrality for their operations, going beyond their Science-Based Target to reduce absolute Scope 1 and 2 emissions 60% from 2016 levels, and reduce absolute upstream value chain (Scope 3) emissions 20% from 2016 levels by 2030. They are currently on pace to meet their scope 1 and 2 targets. The scope 3 emissions, however, remain significantly larger than the scope 1 and 2 emissions combined. Scope 3 emissions come from other parties that a company works with, which makes influencing them more difficult. Collaboration is needed to stimulate companies across the value chain to contribute to sustainability. Collaboration could be in the form of various projects where companies engage in collective action to achieve certain common goals. Collective action means that multiple parties are engaged in a project that works towards a certain shared goal.
This research aims to explore the current challenges of the pharmaceutical sector with reaching emission targets and how collective action concepts impact the willingness of supplier companies to engage in collective initiatives that focus on reducing emissions. For this study, Johnson & Johnson will be analyzed to get a good understanding of the current state of the pharmaceutical sector...


...

A comparative case study of smart grid implementation in three (experimental) community energy projects

The Paris Agreement seeks to limit global temperature rise and achieve climate neutrality by 2050. The UN's Sustainable Development Goal 7 emphasizes sustainable energy access, with smart grids playing a crucial role. These grids adapt to user behavior and interconnect various components. While smart grids address challenges in integrating renewable energy, their complex socio-technical nature demands a multidisciplinary approach. Institutions are vital in smart grid development, but their importance often goes unnoticed. The interplay of stakeholders, technology, and institutions complicates smart grid implementation. Although existing research largely focuses on technical aspects, a holistic approach considering social, economic, environmental, and institutional dimensions is essential. This study aims to bridge this gap by employing the Institutional Analysis & Development (IAD) framework to enhance the Netherlands' electricity/energy system design, particularly at the community level, concerning the impacts of institutional rules on smart grid development and implementation.

The chosen research approach is a comparative case study, focusing on smart grid integration in the Netherlands. The Institutional Analysis and Development framework aids in analyzing complex socio-technical systems, particularly energy transitions and smart grids. Three cases were examined: Schoonschip Amsterdam, GridFlex Heeten, and Groene Mient The Hague. Data collection involved literature review and 14 semi-structured interviews with experts and stakeholders. Interview data was deductively coded using the IAD framework, facilitating comparative case analysis and cross-case analysis using the ASI diagram (Actors, System & Institutions).

The transition of the Dutch electricity system into a competitive liberalized market has increased the importance of smart grids for sustainability. Decentralized energy production, facilitated by smart grids, requires technological advancements and institutional changes at various levels. Successful smart grid implementation in the Netherlands involves obtaining exemptions, feasibility studies, and engaging legal entities like homeowners' associations and energy cooperatives. Cases emphasized the significance of pre-exemption feasibility studies, technological requirements, stakeholders like Distribution System Operators, and energy management systems.

The findings highlight the uniqueness of each case and the role of institutional rules. In Schoonschip, boundary, position, choice, and payoff rules were pivotal. GridFlex highlighted position, choice, information, and scope rules. Groene Mient showcased boundary, position, choice, payoff, and scope rules. These case studies underscore complexities in decision-making and governance within smart grid initiatives. Successful implementation requires considering technology, institutions, and stakeholders as indicated by the ASI diagram. The IAD framework analysis reveals the impact of biophysical conditions, community attributes, and rules-in-use on smart grid outcomes.

Recommendations include further research on evolving rules, understanding actor positions, interdisciplinary research, integrated decision-making frameworks, empirical case studies, and policy recommendations such as financial support, clear policy roles, local smart energy systems, positive framing, standardized data exchange, and umbrella organizations for cohesive local smart grid projects.

In conclusion, the study underscores the intricate nature of smart grid implementation, emphasizing the need for comprehensive consideration of technology, institutions, and stakeholders. The IAD framework sheds light on the complex dynamics, guiding effective decision-making and policy formulation for successful local smart grid development.
...
Master thesis (2023) - A. Ravishankara, Amineh Ghorbani, J.N. Quist
The aviation industry is one of the most challenging sectors to decarbonise. There is an urgent need to reduce emissions in order to meet its committed goal of achieving net-zero flying by 2050. Along with the existing and proposed decarbonization options such as electric aircraft, hydrogen fuel, and operational
improvements, a hard-to-abate sector like aviation would require large amounts of carbon dioxide removal in order to achieve net zero. One such technology-based carbon removal option is Direct Air Capture (DAC) which has the potential to emerge as a potential game-changer to mitigate aviation’s environmental impact. This thesis report presents an analysis of the suitability of adopting DAC for aviation sustainability, viewed through an institutional analysis lens using the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework. DAC is framed as a technology niche from the Multi-Level Perspective to get a descriptive understanding of the problem context and the interconnected parts in the larger picture of aviation sustainability innovations. Specific to DAC, multiple dimensions of DAC integration in the aviation sector, including technology, actors, and policy analysis are carried out. Employing the IAD framework, the underlying institutional arrangements, rules, and incentives influencing the adoption of DAC for carbon removal in the aviation industry are examined.

Data was collected from grey literature, industry reports and interviews with aviation industry professionals. To assess the suitability of DAC for aviation sustainability, various evaluative criteria such as carbon emission reduction potential, technological feasibility, cost-effectiveness, and market acceptance
were considered. There are trade-offs in using DAC for aviation such as complexity in carbon markets, uncertainties in carbon credit pricing, and challenges in accurately measuring DAC’s carbon removal effectiveness. It is seen that DAC holds promise as an innovative carbon removal technology with potential applications in aviation including but not limited to the use in sustainable aviation fuel production. The current state of technology is nascent but the proposed policies under the EU have the potential to drive the commercialization of this technology. The aviation industry stakeholders, along
with carbon market operators, DAC providers, and government policymakers, are key actors involved. The incentives and motivations of actors in determining the success and scalability of DAC for aviation are illustrated.

Based on the analysis, the following recommendations are provided. To minimize residual emissions from aviation, several strategic approaches can be undertaken. Firstly, fostering collaborative research and development among airlines, DAC technology providers, and research institutions can be vital to
tackle technological challenges and creating tailored DAC solutions for aviation. Secondly, governments should extend their support through policy incentives and research grants, encouraging DAC development and integration within the aviation industry. Thirdly, establishing robust standards and certification for DAC-derived Sustainable Aviation Fuel ensures the credibility and quality of carbon removal achieved, further supporting aviation sustainability ...
Master thesis (2023) - A. Arjun Santhosh, Amineh Ghorbani, N. Goyal
Amidst the burgeoning challenges of climate change, certain sectors, like the beer industry, find themselves at the forefront due to their dependence on climate-sensitive agricultural inputs. The changing climatic conditions not only influence the flavor profile but also the beer's accessibility, by affecting the quality and yield of essential ingredients such as barley and hops. This research delves into the beer industry's supply chains, which span regions increasingly vulnerable to climatic disruptions, thereby subjecting companies to notable physical risks like water shortages, crop failures, and transportation hindrances.

The pertinence of this study extends beyond the beer industry, revealing broader implications for various business sectors. As supply chains of numerous sectors traverse climate-sensitive zones, they're endangered by hazards like droughts and heatwaves. A prominent challenge exacerbating these threats is poor coordination, evidenced by inconsistent communication, delayed responses to disruptions, supply chain opaqueness, and misaligned adaptive strategies.

To address the overarching research question on effective coordination measures that the beer supply chain can adopt to mitigate vulnerabilities and bolster climate resilience, the study integrates both primary and secondary data. Primary data is sourced through semi-structured interviews, capturing insights from within the beer industry, while secondary data is derived from academic and industry repositories. The combined data offers a comprehensive perspective on the existing challenges and potential solutions for the beer supply chain.

A deep dive into the industry's supply chain relationships elucidates the inherent complexities, informing subsequent analyses on viable coordination mechanisms to combat climate vulnerabilities. Heineken, an industry stalwart, plays a crucial role in this exploration, with the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework assisting in structuring the problem analysis. This framework is invaluable in scrutinizing institutional setups and their resultant impacts, while Heineken's strategic initiatives are evaluated using action situation analysis.

One of the central themes emerging from the findings is the potential applicability of Elinor Ostrom's design principles. Originally conceived for effective common-pool resource management, these principles, emphasizing clear demarcation, rule-local condition congruence, and responsible governance, could be instrumental for the beer industry. They present a well-structured approach for devising coordination mechanisms, crucial in confronting collective environmental challenges.

In summation, this research underscores the imperative for the beer industry, and by extension, other sectors, to consider Ostrom's principles. Their adoption could pave the way for resilient and sustainable supply chains, proficient in circumventing climate-induced risks. Such proactive measures are not merely pivotal for sustaining business operations but paramount in ushering an era of sustainable, climate-resilient business practices. ...

A qualitative research on the practical impact of the Green Deal Sustainable Healthcare 3.0 in the Netherlands

The third version of the Green Deal Sustainable Healthcare 3.0 (GD3) in the Dutch elderly care sector represents a dynamic and shared governance model that promotes widespread participation and implementation of sustainability practices. The GD3 provides a blueprint for elderly care organisations to pursue sustainability goals, but its success depends on collaborative efforts supported by various tools and frameworks. This research explores how joining the GD3 facilitates the achievement of sustainability goals in elderly care organisations. Successful implementation of the GD3 can have far-reaching effects, of which inspiring other sectors to adopt similar collaborative approaches. However, its effectiveness depends on the performance of the participating organisations and their use of empowering tools such as the Milieuthermometer Zorg (MTZ). Interaction and cooperation between the diverse group of actors is essential to achieve the desired results, as the GD3 operates through a shared form of governance involving both bottom-up and governmental actors. Active participation, implementation of sustainable actions and maintaining trust and cooperation are crucial for the effectiveness of the GD3. Repeated experience with climate agreements such as the GD3 helps to build trust, reciprocity and reputation among participating actors. All of this is being explored in the context of other challenges specific to care for the elderly, such as staff shortages and an ageing population. Ultimately, the GD3 represents a valuable initiative within the health sector that provides a script for sustainability efforts, while allowing organisations the flexibility to adapt and take artistic license in achieving the intended outcomes. The aim is to present a dazzling sustainability show within three years, signalling a transformed system. Given the urgency of sustainability and the challenges posed by an ageing population, embracing GD3's collaborative and adaptive approach is essential for the future of healthcare, particularly in the context of elderly care in the Netherlands. ...
Master thesis (2023) - A.M.J. Reitsema, G. Korevaar, A. Ghorbani
Reducing packaging waste is a pressing challenge requiring organisations to look beyond their own products, services and business models and take an ecosystem approach. Collaborative efforts in circular ecosystems offer a promising solution to tackle this issue. However, the impact of circular ecosystems on material flows in the packaging system, particularly considering uncertain actor behavior, remains unknown. This thesis aims to address this research gap by studying the dynamics of packaging waste in a circular food packaging ecosystem in the Netherlands.

Using a complex adaptive socio-technical systems approach, the research combines a systematic literature review and a case study with interviews to develop an agent-based model (ABM). The ABM incorporates three types of agents representing food producers, packaging producers, and waste treaters, who can form circular ecosystems focused on closed-loop recycling. Organisational decision-making theory is integrated into the ABM to account for actor behavior, considering different decision-styles and decision-rules.

The ABM explores the effect of multiple variables on packaging waste dynamics in circular ecosystems. Results indicate that circular ecosystems can be established with only a few actors prioritising circularity over individual profit, leading to significant reductions in packaging waste. The decision-style of the food producer plays a crucial role in ecosystems dominated by actors prioritising individual profit. However, availability and sharing of information on recycled material volumes and content are critical for circular ecosystems to emerge.

Circular ecosystems may face limitations due to recycled material shortages, leading to fluctuations in recycled content. Centralised waste treatment can stabilise recycled material supply and, subsequently, recycled content in packaging. Technological innovations hold potential for increasing recycled content and recycling rates, but additional changes in actor behavior and material prices are needed to utilise this potential. On top of that, other high-level circularity strategies should be employed to overcome limitations related to material shortage. Using recycled material could be incentivised through subsidies or taxes on raw materials, but the effectiveness of such measures will depend on the decision-making of the packaging producers.

The discussion reflects on the results, the ABM, and the overall research, identifying limitations and implications and suggesting future research directions. Further refinements to the ABM can enhance its accuracy and suitability for analysing circular ecosystems for waste reduction.

In conclusion, this research sheds light on the dynamics of packaging waste in a circular food packaging ecosystem in the Netherlands, considering actor behavior. The ABM provides a valuable analytical tool for studying circular ecosystems and their potential in the food packaging industry. By emphasizing actor collaboration, circular packaging ecosystems offer a pathway to a more sustainable food packaging industry. ...
Master thesis (2023) - C. van der Pol, A. Ghorbani, T. Hoppe
Decentralised solar electricity generation on a large scale is a relatively new phenomenon. In the State of New York, the adoption of this form of renewable electricity generation has seen a surge over the last decade. However, policies that have been implemented over the last year, prompted experts to question the future of the market. The question is, what are the effects on energy security when these policies are in place? Using 3 relevant theories (TPB, VBN, and DOI) on household decision-making processes, a study of what is meant by decentralised solar and the context in which the market operates in the Empire State, I used an agent-based model to analyse the impacts of these policies in terms of energy security. Energy security is defined into 6 dimensions (Availability, Affordability, Accessibility, Acceptability, Ability, and Appeal). Experimentation and subsequent analysis showed a limited effect on most of these terms. However, a combination of these policies showed a less favourable effect on all scenarios as compared to the business-as-usual scenario. What was salient during experimentation was that the combination of the policies led to a difference in direction of the effects than when the effects of the policies implemented in isolation were added together. Indicating an inter-relationship between policies. Moreover, during market analysis it was found that the influence of the traditional utilities (owned by private investors) exert great influence on the policy making process, in their own favour. Based on this research, the future of decentralised solar electricity generation in the State of New York is going to be a tough battle with the greatest hurdle being overcoming the power of centralised utilities. ...
Master thesis (2023) - M. Lehmkühler, Amineh Ghorbani, K. Blok
This research investigates the role of International Cooperative Initiatives (ICIs) in supporting the Netherlands’ national climate targets, with a specific focus on the chemical sector. The chemical industry is a critical contributor to national greenhouse gas emissions, while also being highly interconnected with global supply chains. ICIs, which include voluntary agreements, international partnerships, and sector-specific coalitions, offer a mechanism for sharing best practices, accessing technological innovations, and aligning industrial activities with climate objectives beyond national borders. Understanding their effectiveness is essential for both policymakers and industry actors aiming to meet ambitious emission reduction targets while maintaining competitiveness.

The study examines how chemical sector companies in the Netherlands participate in ICIs and to what extent these initiatives influence their climate performance. Data were collected through a mixed-method approach, including a review of policy documents, corporate sustainability reports, and publicly available records of participation in ICIs. Additionally, semi-structured interviews were conducted with industry representatives, policymakers, and experts from ICIs to obtain qualitative insights into the mechanisms, benefits, and challenges of these collaborative efforts.

Findings indicate that ICIs play a multifaceted role in advancing national climate goals. First, they enable knowledge transfer and capacity building, allowing Dutch chemical companies to adopt innovative low-carbon technologies and operational practices more rapidly than would be possible through national efforts alone. Second, ICIs provide reputational and regulatory incentives, as participation can signal corporate commitment to sustainability and facilitate alignment with international climate standards. Third, they foster the development of joint projects and sector-wide initiatives, enabling scale effects that amplify the impact of individual corporate actions.

However, the research also identifies several challenges. The voluntary nature of many ICIs can limit enforcement, and discrepancies between international standards and national climate policies may create coordination issues. Furthermore, participation requires significant organizational resources, which may disadvantage smaller firms or create inequalities in influence among participants. Despite these challenges, ICIs were found to have a positive effect on the chemical sector’s ability to meet emission reduction targets, particularly when initiatives are well-integrated with national policy frameworks and include clear performance indicators.

The study concludes that ICIs are an important complement to national climate policy in the Netherlands. To maximize their effectiveness, policymakers should encourage alignment between ICIs and national targets, provide support for smaller firms to participate, and promote transparency and monitoring mechanisms. For the chemical sector, active engagement in ICIs can accelerate the adoption of low-carbon technologies, strengthen global competitiveness, and enhance contributions to national climate objectives.

Overall, this research contributes to the understanding of how international collaboration mechanisms can support domestic climate ambitions, highlighting the benefits and limitations of ICIs in translating global cooperation into measurable national outcomes. ...

Encouraging Circular Wood-Based Building Practises in Amsterdam

The aim of this thesis project is to understand how policy instruments influence the adoption of wood-based building practices and to examine the effect of increased wood-based construction on circular practices. This study identifies key actors in the built environment, including housing associations, private owners, construction and demolition companies, and material suppliers. The behavior and relationships of these actors are analyzed. An agent-based model is developed to explore the impact of various policy instruments, such as carbon taxation, demolition notification, and knowledge sharing. The study revealed several findings. First, there is significant inertia among construction compa- nies and building owners towards adopting wood-based construction, primarily due to high initial investments and lack of familiarity. This results in a hefty premium being paid for wood-based construction before it becomes well established. It was discovered that a substantial subsidy on mass timber is essential. Additionally, significant taxation on reinforced concrete, such as through carbon taxation, helps overcome the inertia in the system. Another effective instrument is the sharing of wood-based construction knowledge among construction companies. Once wood-based construction is established, it becomes cost-competitive, reducing the need for continuous stimu- lation through policy instruments. With the establishment of wood-based construction, several effects on the circularity in the built environment and material usage have been identified. Despite a shift to wood-based construction, the demand for concrete remains significant. This underscores the importance of concrete recycling practices. The increase in wood content in construction requires enhanced mass-timber recycling practices. This study highlights the role of temporary material storage in facilitating circularity. It suggests the need for strategies to match material streams from demolition to construction. In summary, this thesis project demonstrates that a combination of policy instruments, especially carbon taxation and knowledge sharing, is crucial in transitioning to wood-based construction. The study highlights the need for continued attention to concrete use and recycling, especially when wood-based practices gain traction. ...