M. Despotopoulou
Please Note
3 records found
1
The Needle in the Haystack
A Multi-Analytical Approach for the Identification of Palaeolithic Adhesive Residues at Morín Cave, Spain
Adhesives are central to debates on the cognitive and technological capabilities of Neanderthals and modern humans. Spectrometric and chemical analyses suggest that Neanderthals relied primarily on birch bark tar, with some use of bitumen and conifer resin, whereas modern humans employed a broader range of materials, including resins, gums, tars, beeswax, and bitumen, sometimes mixed with inorganic additives. This evidence reveals a complex and varied technological landscape in which adhesive recipes were shaped by raw material availability, functional requirements, and cultural traditions. To explore Palaeolithic adhesive technology, we applied a multi-analytical approach—including optical and scanning electron microscopy, spectrometry, and chemical analyses—to lithic assemblages spanning the entire sequence of Morín Cave, northern Spain. This integrated protocol enabled us to distinguish modern contaminants from residues of probable archaeological origin and to suggest the presence of adhesives on a Châtelperronian and a Gravettian tool. Gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC-MS) detected resin or tar from a Cupressaceae plant on the Châtelperronian point, while potential insect wax, plant wax, or bitumen was identified on the Gravettian tool. Together with earlier observations of possible adhesive residues at Morín (Bradtmöller et al., Journal of Archaeological Science, 7:1-13, 2016), these findings increase the number of chemically supported cases to four, making the site one of the few in Europe with potential adhesive evidence spanning multiple Palaeolithic technocomplexes. The residues are consistent with hafting applications, likely linked to projectile technology, though the degree of certainty varies. Although the limited number of identified residues and difficulties in precise characterisation prevent direct comparison of Neanderthal and modern human adhesive traditions at Morín Cave, our results provide insights into Palaeolithic adhesive use. More importantly, they demonstrate the potential of a multi-analytical methodology to disentangle ancient residues from modern contaminants and to advance the systematic study of prehistoric adhesive technologies.
Archaeological findings prove the appearance and use of birch bark tar since the Middle Palaeolithic. The production and use of birch bark tar and pine wood tar has overlapped since at least the late Neolithic, but probably for much longer. The reliable chemical identification of such archaeological tar residues can offer valuable insights into, for example, ancient technical complexity, trade and culture. In this context, the scarcity of these mainly organic residue findings in the archaeological record bears the need for non-destructive analytical tools. However, there is currently no systematic proposed way for this purpose. We aim here to verify the organic nature and test the reliability of the identification of archaeological pine wood tar and birch bark tar with a combination of SEM-EDS, FTIR microspectroscopy in reflectance mode and XRD. We examined a set of experimental adhesive replicas of pine tar and birch tar in pristine form, but also after a three-year-long weathering experiment. Additionally, we studied a set of archaeological samples, consisting of Mesolithic bone/antler points with adhering hafting residues, form the Dutch North Sea. This research shows that degradation negatively influences the reliable verification and identification of the organic residue constituents significantly. SEM-EDS as a starting point of analysis verifies the residue's organic nature, but it cannot be used to identify birch or pine tar. XRD can identify crystalline additives in the adhesive mixture, like ochre and wax, as well as phases related to the artefact's environment of burial and provenance. Micro-FTIR is also capable of verifying the organic matter of the residue constituents. The differentiation of birch and pine tars is hindered by vibrational modes occurring in neighbouring wavenumbers for both tars, and by the limited research on degradation markers indicative of thermal treatment to prove tar production. Until reference collections also account for degradation and include a wide variety of adhesives, results of FTIR collected in reflectance mode are best treated with some caution.