Cap Metric and LCA Weighted Permit Price Design Options for a Resource Cap-and-Trade System
Designing a Material Allowance Trading Scheme (MATS) to Steer EU Environmental Footprint Below Planetary Boundaries
J.W.J. van Bemmelen (TU Delft - Technology, Policy and Management)
D.P. Peck – Graduation committee member (TU Delft - Architecture and the Built Environment)
Lauran van Oers – Graduation committee member (Universiteit Leiden)
More Info
expand_more
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Abstract
The persistent expansion of global material use and the subsequent transgression of planetary boundaries (PB's) necessitate a fundamental restructuring of European environmental governance. While the European Union has implemented various strategies under the green growth paradigm, including the Green Deal and the Circular Economy Action Plan, these frameworks have failed to achieve the absolute decoupling of economic activity from environmental degradation. Current policy efforts primarily focus on relative efficiency gains, which are consistently neutralised by the increasing volume of consumption and production. This research identifies a critical gap in the scientific discourse: while the necessity of resource caps is recognised, there remains a lack of concrete, conceptual designs for such regulatory instruments. Consequently, this thesis develops the Material Allowance Trading Scheme (MATS), a conceptual cap-and-trade framework designed to steer the EU’s societal metabolism back within planetary boundaries.
The methodology integrates a literature review with a modelling exercise that utilises the functional architecture of the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) as a blueprint. By synthesising literature through a problem-solution lens, the research identifies the gap between environmental research and governance, leading to the need for a macro-scale resource cap. The proposed MATS framework employs a mass-based regulated metric, specifically targeting a reduction in total material throughput. Aligning with the Planetary Boundary framework, the cap is set to converge toward a sustainable target of 5 to 8 tonnes per capita by 2050, aligning the EU’s resource use with the planetary boundaries of the Earth system.
A central feature of the design is the implementation of an impact-weighted permit pricing mechanism. Recognising that different materials possess varying ecological footprints, the scheme utilises Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) data and the Distance-to-Target method to adjust permit costs. This ensures that high-impact materials carry a proportionally higher regulatory cost, thereby incentivising the market to prioritise low-impact alternatives. The regulation is designed to target extractors and importers, while incorporating Material Passports for finished goods to prevent leakage. The findings demonstrate that a resource cap-and-trade system is a technically feasible and theoretically grounded necessary instrument to steer the EU's environmental footprint below planetary boundaries. By bridging the gap between theoretical PB's and tangible policy formulation, this research provides a necessary foundation for the academic and political debate on absolute resource reduction. The MATS represents a shift from productivity-based governance toward a governance model defined by binding biophysical constraints.