What should be automated in offices? Occupants' preferences for automation levels from a large survey in Spain and the Netherlands

Journal Article (2026)
Author(s)

Pedro de la Barra (TU Delft - Architecture and the Built Environment)

Pablo Martinez-Alcaraz (TU Delft - Architecture and the Built Environment)

Eleonora Brembilla (TU Delft - Architecture and the Built Environment)

Alessandra Luna-Navarro (TU Delft - Architecture and the Built Environment)

Research Group
Building Design & Technology
DOI related publication
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2026.118348 Final published version
More Info
expand_more
Publication Year
2026
Language
English
Research Group
Building Design & Technology
Journal title
Energy and Buildings
Volume number
373
Article number
118348
Page Views
25
Reuse Rights

Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.

Abstract

Occupant-centered building control requires defining not only which building services should be automated but also the role occupants prefer to retain in the control loop. However, empirical evidence remains fragmented across single services, leaving a gap in understanding how preferred automation levels varies across building services and daily routines. This study establishes an evidence-based typology for occupant-centered building automation, mapping preferences across ten services and three workday phases through a large-scale questionnaire of 3504 office workers in the Netherlands and Spain. Using a consistent five-level automation scale, we map preferences across ten building services and three distinct workday phases (arrival, active work, and leaving). Results show that automation preferences are context-dependent, varying according to the specific building service and the current workday phase. HVAC systems, particularly mechanical ventilation, show the strongest acceptance of automated control, whereas directly reachable elements, such as openable windows and personal devices, are predominantly preferred under manual control. A primary finding of this study is the prevalence of ‘mixed-control’ profiles (61.5% of respondents), showing that occupants' desire for personal control is service-dependent. Furthermore, we provide empirical evidence of the interaction strategy gap, demonstrating that higher automation acceptance is statistically contingent upon digital, desk-reachable, and information-rich control interfaces. Prior experience with automated systems emerged as the most consistent predictor of acceptance of automation, suggesting that trust in the control loop is experience-based. These findings argue against one-size-fits-all automation and provide empirical basis for designing adaptive, service-specific control strategies that balance building energy goals with occupant agency.