Towards Adaptive & Robust Tension Control for an Offshore Heavy-Lift Load Tugger System
D. Feberwee (TU Delft - Mechanical Engineering)
B. De Schutter – Mentor (TU Delft - Mechanical Engineering)
Daan Vis – Mentor (Huisman Equipment BV)
R.D. McAllister – Graduation committee member (TU Delft - Mechanical Engineering)
More Info
expand_more
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Abstract
Imagine being flown offshore by helicopter to retune the tension controller of a crane, because its load tugger system became unstable during operation. Such behaviour is costly and directly affects the safety and workability of offshore heavy-lift operations. Load tugger systems, consisting of a variable frequency drive, a winch and a tugger wire, control the wave induced motion of the payload. Their operating conditions change continuously: the wire length varies, payloads range from light blades to heavy structures, and the disturbances differ over time. The current fixed-gain PI controller works well at its commissioning conditions, but loses performance and can become unstable when these conditions change.
This thesis investigates how Model Predictive Control (MPC) can improve the robustness, adaptability and performance of tension control under varying conditions, and whether it is suitable for industrial deployment. A four-state linear state-space model was derived and validated against a linear spring model of the tugger system. Four controllers were compared: the industrial PI baseline, a linear MPC controller, a MPC controller scheduled on the effective wire length, and this scheduled controller with a disturbance model. All were tuned with the same procedure and evaluated in five test cases on a nonlinear catenary model, which introduces realistic model mismatch.
The scheduled MPC controller with disturbance rejection performed best: compared to the PI controller, it reduced the mean integrated relative error by 75% and the number of failed runs from 27 to 10 out of 54, because it anticipates the payload motion instead of reacting to a tension error. Scheduling alone reduced the error by about 20% under disturbances, whereas MPC with a single model gave no meaningful improvement. The disturbance model, however, assumes a known disturbance period and made the controller the most sensitive to loop delay. Deployment therefore requires that the period can be provided, the loop delay stays small and the optimisation can be solved within the cycle time of the control hardware. Until then, the scheduled MPC controller is the most suitable next step from the current PI controller.
Files
File under embargo until 25-11-2028