Assessment of local land cover change on the streamflow dynamics in tropical montane cloud forest region, Alta Verapaz, Guatemala

Abstract

The applicability of the FLEX-Topo and FIESTA models in simulating the impacts of land cover change on the streamflow dynamics in the tropical montane cloud forest of the Mestelá catchment, Alta Verapaz, Guatemala was investigated. Understanding these impacts is crucial for effective water resource management in regions vulnerable to deforestation, where cloud forests play a critical role in regulating hydrological processes, and in areas prone to flooding and droughts.

The FIESTA model was integrated to generate spatially distributed meteorological inputs, tailored to unique spatial characteristics of the tropical montane cloud forest region. These inputs informed the FLEX-Topo model, which was adapted to conceptualize the dominant hydrological processes in the study area for simulating streamflow in the Mestelá catchment. The model was calibrated to represent distinct land use classes within the catchment using multi-criteria calibration with different objective functions and constraints to account for parameter uncertainty. Scenario-based simulations, including deforestation, reforestation and the conversion of agricultural land to pine plantations, were conducted to quantify their effects on streamflow dynamics, water balance components and extreme hydrological
events.

The integration of the FIESTA model provided spatially distributed inputs, however further evaluation is needed to assess the accuracy of this distribution. Its spatial variability enabled the inclusion of fog interception into the water balance, representing a key hydrological process in cloud forests. Calibration of the FLEX-Topo model was achieved by optimizing parameters for distinct land use classes and using dynamic land use fractions. Scenario analysis revealed that deforestation potentially increased peak flows by 18.5% (±1.4%), while restoring forest cover reduced extreme flows by 39.5% (±1.9%), highlighting the role of reforestation in flood mitigation. Replacing agriculture with pine trees on steep slopes also reduced extreme flows, while additionally addressing landslide risks.

The combined application of the FLEX-Topo and FIESTA models offers valuable insights into hydrological responses to land use changes, particularly in cloud forest regions, highlighting their potential for informing policy decisions related to land conservation and water management in tropical montane cloud forests.