Criterion Water Treatment Plant, Upcycling Waste Sludge
What is a feasible sludge management strategy for Criterion Water Treatment Plant considering local constraints, technical feasibility, economic viability and environmental impact?
F.Q. Armstrong Hall (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
L.C. Rietveld – Mentor (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
E. Mostert – Graduation committee member (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
M.K. de Kreuk – Graduation committee member (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
More Info
expand_more
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Abstract
Criterion Water Treatment Plant supplies drinking water to Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, using aluminium sulphate as its primary coagulant. The resulting coagulation flocculation (CF) sludge is discharged to sludge ponds and sludge fields without further treatment, a practice that concentrates aluminium in the surrounding soil. This presents a risk to the local environment and has been identified as a concern by both Bulawayo City Council (BCC) and the African Development Bank. This thesis asks what constitutes a feasible sludge management strategy for Criterion, considering local constraints, technical feasibility, economic viability and environmental impact.
The question was addressed in four steps: a literature review of water treatment sludge characteristics, environmental and health impacts, regulation and management strategies; a characterisation of Criterion's sludge combining BCC historical monitoring data with samples analysed at the TU Delft WaterLab; a multi-criteria analysis developed in a workshop with BCC staff; and a techno-economic business case for the highest-ranked option.
Characterisation showed a strongly aluminium dominant sludge, with almost all of the dosed aluminium retained in the clarifiers sludge, supporting further assessment of coagulant recovery (CR). The MCA assessed seven strategies and produced a leading cluster separated by only twelve points: CR via the REAL process (354), sewage sludge dewatering (344) and use as a constructed wetland substrate (342). The CR REAL process was developed into a conceptual design of three identical trains on a 105,000 m³/d design basis, comprising a process flow diagram, stream tables, a mass-balance model, equipment sizing, site selection and an AACE Class 5 cost estimate.
The model recovers approximately 82.3% of the incoming aluminium as potassium aluminium sulphate, but returns an installed CAPEX of approximately $5.81 million, a gross annual OPEX of approximately $15.47 million and a net present value of approximately −$135.83 million over a twenty year life. Ultrafiltration feed heating accounts for 63% of operating cost, because Criterions feed is roughly 141 times more dilute in aluminium than the pilot feed on which the process was validated. Thickening the sludge upstream reduces gross OPEX by approximately 97% and the NPV shortfall to approximately −$4.24 million.
The thesis concludes that no strategy is ready for immediate full-scale implementation. It instead supports a staged pathway of year-round sludge monitoring, a broadened MCA and proportionate feasibility studies of the three leading options, with a Criterion-specific REAL pilot incorporating upstream thickening as the priority technical investigation.