Scaling Beyond The Pilot: Stakeholder Involvement In Dutch Living Labs And Field Labs
D.V. Alkemade (TU Delft - Industrial Design Engineering)
T.A.P. Metze – Graduation committee member (TU Delft - Technology, Policy and Management)
I.J. Mulder – Graduation committee member (TU Delft - Industrial Design Engineering)
J.B. Cohen – Mentor (TU Delft - Technology, Policy and Management)
More Info
expand_more
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Abstract
Accelerating sustainability transitions requires moving innovations from experimental testbeds into mainstream practice. Across the Netherlands, Living Labs and Field Labs have emerged as environments in which technological, organisational and social innovations can be tested in real-world settings. However, successful experimentation within these testing environments does not necessarily result in development or adoption beyond the pilot. This is reflected in the ‘pilot paradox’, where projects can achieve their experimental objectives while remaining limited in their ability to develop beyond the pilot.
Stakeholder involvement is important in this process because stakeholders can provide knowledge, resources and access to the contexts in which innovations need to be implemented. At the same time, previous research shows that identifying, attracting and maintaining stakeholder involvement can be difficult. This thesis therefore investigates the challenges that projects themselves encounter when organising stakeholder involvement to support developments beyond the pilot.
The aim of this thesis is to understand how stakeholder involvement is organised in Dutch Living Labs and Field Labs and to identify the challenges that constrain stakeholder involvement in supporting scaling beyond the pilot. The central research question asks: What challenges do projects within Dutch Living Labs and Field Labs encounter when involving stakeholders to support scaling beyond the pilot?
A qualitative multiple-case study was conducted on three innovation projects in a Dutch Living Lab and Field Lab. Two cases took place at The Green Village in Delft and one case took place at Energie-Lab Zuid Oost in Amsterdam. Data were collected through project documentation, participant observations and 15 semi-structured interviews with actors from governmental institutions, Living and Field Labs, industry, and residents. The data were analysed using abductive thematic coding.
The findings show that stakeholder involvement was dynamic rather than continuous. Several challenges in involving stakeholders to support scaling beyond the pilot were identified within the case studies. These challenges occur on both sides of the involvement process, as both project teams and stakeholders face challenges that can limit involvement. 6 categories were identified: (1) limited resources and capacity; (2) identifying and reaching relevant stakeholders; (3) perceived relevance and willingness to participate; (4) meaningful participation and influence; (5) institutional and commercial constraints; and (6) project purpose and development stage.
The main implication is that deliberate choices need to be made within projects about the relevance of stakeholders at different stages, how they can realistically participate, and what opportunities they have to contribute. The study recommends more flexible approaches to involvement, explicit attention to representation and power, and participation methods that are adapted to stakeholder capacities and project needs. The main limitations are the retrospective design, the focus on three cases within two experimental environments, and the emphasis on actors who were already connected to the projects. Future research should therefore also investigate the perspectives of stakeholders who were not involved but could have been relevant and examine how meaningful stakeholder involvement can be organised under the practical and institutional constraints of real-world experimentation.