Stocking up for winter
Quantifying the trade-off between robust and efficient fleet scheduling for public transit operating under energy consumption uncertainty
S.F.J. Buisman (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
N. van Oort – Mentor (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
P.S.A. Stokkink – Mentor (TU Delft - Technology, Policy and Management)
J.E.B. Bickel – Mentor (TU Delft - Civil Engineering & Geosciences)
Maxim Meijers – Mentor
More Info
expand_more
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Abstract
Public transport operators increasingly rely on battery electric buses to reduce emissions. These buses have a limited range and their energy consumption fluctuates. To prevent buses from running out of energy, vehicle schedules are planned with extra energy redundancy on top of the expected energy consumption. A higher redundancy makes a schedule more robust but less efficient. However, the size of this trade-off has hardly been quantified for electric buses. Therefore, this study quantifies how the energy consumption value that is assumed during planning affects the robustness and efficiency of electric bus schedules.
The research is done in cooperation with EBS. A four-step framework is developed and applied to two depots in the Dutch region IJssel-Vecht. First, a regression model estimates energy consumption from a year of trip data. Second, scenarios for cold days and passenger numbers are defined. Third, a discrete event and Monte Carlo simulation assesses how many trips are cancelled. Fourth, the actual schedule is compared with four schedules planned with a 10% and 20% lower or higher energy consumption.
Temperature is the most important factor for energy consumption. Planning with a lower value leads to a sharp rise in cancelled trips and in costs for passengers and the operator, whereas planning with a higher value reduces delays at a limited cost. This effect is asymmetric, and larger at the depot with slow chargers at the depot than at the depot with fast chargers at the hub. Cutting robustness to save cost can therefore end up costing more. Whether a higher energy redundancy also pays off for the operator depends on its effect on driver schedules. The framework lets operators stress-test fleet schedules under local conditions. Limitations are the black-box scheduling software used for the alternative schedules and assumptions on personnel cost. Further research should focus on integrating transparent fleet and crew schedule optimisation.