Evaluating EMF Emissions in Submarine HVAC Cables

Abstract

This thesis investigates the impact of geometric, material, and operational parameters on the electromagnetic fields (EMFs) emitted by submarine power cables, particularly those used for offshore wind power transmission. The study is essential due to the growing deployment of offshore wind farms and the corresponding need for efficient submarine power transmission systems, combined with ecological concerns. The primary focus is on high-voltage alternating current (HVAC) cables, commonly used to connect offshore wind farms to the onshore grid. The rapid expansion of offshore wind power has highlighted significant ecological and environmental concerns, especially the effects of EMFs on marine life. Species such as elasmobranchs (sharks, rays, and skates) are highly sensitive to EMFs, making this an important area of research. The objective of this thesis is to develop guidelines for modeling EMFs from submarine power cables to aid ecological research, focusing on establishing effective parameters for EMF emission models. A literature review has shown that EMFs can impact marine animals’ navigation, predator-prey relationships, and embryo- genic development. Elasmobranchs, in particular, are vulnerable due to their sensitivity to EMFs. The review highlights the necessary accuracy levels for EMF models, focusing on HVAC cables. Starting with the basic physics including Maxwell’s equations, the Biot-Savart law, and the Lorentz force, followed by an outline of HVAC cable and transmission system design parameters, an understanding was created of the electromagnetic phenomena occurring in a submarine power cable. It was concluded that modeling EMFs requires considering current distribution along the conductor and metallic sheath, and the local interactions between cable components that result in shielding of the EMFs. A method from literature was used for predicting the longitudinal distribution of current along the conductor. The current distribution was affected by voltage and current transmission requirements, impedance, and the capacitive and inductive properties of the phases as well as reactive power compensation. Analyzing these parameters showed that all are crucial for accurate EMF modeling, as parameter changes within realistic ranges could result in differences over 10%. A significant part of this thesis examines the intensity of the metallic sheath currents. Modern HVAC cable designs use conductive polyethylene layers around the metallic sheaths, creating an electrical interface between them. This was conventionally assumed to dissipate circulating currents in the sheath, but this thesis questioned this belief. It was proven that some circulating currents remain and that induced currents were even unaffected by the conductive interface. The induced currents in the metallic sheath are shown to only be influenced by the conduction current and its design parameters, inductance, and resistance per unit length. Testing on the Borssele Alpha cable showed that sheath current for all standard operations was more than 12% of the conduction current. An analysis of the local impact of various design and operational parameters on EMF emissions was conducted using COMSOL Multiphysics. The Borssele Alpha 1 cable design served as a standard test case. The analysis highlighted the importance of the metallic sheath and even more so, the armor layer. The steel armor layer created a path of low reluctance, with geometric parameters and permeability playing significant roles. The effect of twist in the phases and armor wires on field emissions was also shown. The lay-length of the phases played a large role due to its effect on destructive interference between emissions of different phases. The armor lay-length had a considerable impact as well, possibly affecting the reluctance of the armor layer. The parameter analysis also confirmed the validity of an ultra-shortened section length in COMSOL, greatly reducing simulation time without impacting results. This research provides insights for developing accurate EMF emission predictions, aiding biologists and ecologists in evaluating the environmental impacts of offshore wind power infrastructure. This can guide the development of mitigation strategies and support sustainable expansion of renewable energy sources. Recommendations for future research include experimental testing of the sheath current model, further development of the transmission line method for the metallic sheath and developing better mitigation strategies. Unrelated to the main question is that in thermal analysis of comparable submarine power cable designs, the induced current must be incorporated, as it was unclear if this is the case. The findings of this thesis can significantly contribute to the sustainable growth of offshore wind power by addressing ecological concerns and improving the understanding of EMF effects on marine life.