Composite single-lap shear joints made from virgin plies and recycled core material are manufactured via induction and conduction welding using T300/polyphenylene sulfide (T300/PPS) as well as T700/low-melt polyaryletherketone (T700/LM-PAEK). The specimens are tested in quasi-static conditions to evaluate their mechanical performance and damage growth. Digital image correlation and high-speed cameras are used to capture the specimen behavior until after failure. While joints with recycled core material show a lower load-transferring capacity than their virgin counterparts (reduction of 13.8% for T300/PPS and 41.2% for T700/LM-PAEK), they are nonetheless an appealing option for applications where sustainability is a priority. Damage in virgin thermoplastic welded single-lap shear joints grows along the weld line. Conversely, specimens containing recycled core material may also experience delaminations between the core and the virgin outer plies. This suggests that thermoplastic welding can create interfaces with higher fracture toughness properties than those achieved during the consolidation of the base laminates. @en

Welded omega-stiffened panels made of thermoplastic carbon composite with initial damage in the conduction welded joint are analysed and tested to investigate the damage tolerance in post-buckling. Finite element analyses are performed, using the virtual crack closure technique to investigate skin-stringer separation for both the pristine welded joint and joints with initial damage. A sensitivity study is executed for the initial damage size and location with different geometrical imperfections. Four omega-stiffened panels are tested, of which three have initial damage consisting of a foil at the welded skin-stringer interface. During the test, digital image correlation is used to measure the panels’ deformation to determine the evolution of the buckling shape and the interaction with the initial damage. A high-speed camera is placed on the stringer side of the panel to capture the final failure. The panels fail in post-buckling when skin-stringer separation occurs, starting from the initial damage. The finite element analysis is able to predict the overall structural behaviour well, with conservative failure load predictions for panels with initial damage in the middle stringer. Although the initial buckling shape is predicted well, the buckling shape evolution at higher loads is difficult to predict.@en

In this research, conduction welded C-struts, part of a thermoplastic composite fuselage designed and manufactured in the framework of the Clean Sky 2 STUNNING project, are investigated. Five specimens made of two C-section profiles are manufactured and welded using conduction welding in three different configurations with variations in the direction and distance of the two welded joints. Preliminary numerical analysis using the virtual crack closure technique are conducted to obtain an initial evaluation of the specimens behavior, in preparation of the tests. Experiments are performed under quasi-static loading conditions to measure the strength of the welds. Comparisons with the preliminary numerical analyses show a good agreement in terms of the predicted maximum load, while a clear difference is observed in the initial stiffness, due to the compliance of the support structure. The numerical model is updated, leading to results that closely match the experimental behavior. For all the analyzed specimens, the separation occurs suddenly and no signs of propagation are observed. Experimental and numerical data show no relevant difference in the joint strength among the different conduction welding configurations.

@en

Traditionally, launch vehicles are constructed with a series of buckling-prone thin-walled cylindrical and conical shells, in which the buckling behavior of these shells has been well studied and buckling design guidance exists. Conical-cylindrical shell geometry is now being utilized for launch-vehicle stage adapters and payload adapters due to advances in manufacturing and numerical techniques, but there is no available buckling design guidance for this nontraditional combined geometry. In order to provide design recommendations, the buckling behavior and imperfection sensitivity of conical-cylindrical shells and how it differs from the conical and cylindrical components needs to be better understood. From this premise, it is possible to investigate whether or not the buckling knockdown factor guidelines for conical and cylindrical shells outlined in NASA SP-8019 and NASA SP-8007, respectively, are still applicable. The results in this paper will show that the current recommendations are not appropriate in some cases. In addition, it was observed that the large rotations and displacements near the transition between the cone and cylinder can have a larger effect on the buckling load than the presence of radial imperfections for conical-cylindrical shells, which is different than for conical or cylindrical shells. More interesting is the fact that design modifications to increase the buckling capability of a conical-cylindrical shell such as adding reinforcement, which may add mass, will make the shell more sensitive to imperfections. The increased imperfection sensitivity may negate the increase in buckling capability that was thought to be achievable. In the end, it may be more beneficial to design a conical-cylindrical shell in which the buckling behavior is dominated by the more predictable geometric nonlinearity, which may lead to an overall lower buckling load, but a lower knockdown factor may be possible since it will not be as sensitive to the lessknown radial imperfections.

@en

This paper presents a numerical approach for investigating fatigue delamination propagation in composite stiffened panels loaded in compression in the post-buckling field. These components are widely utilized in aerospace structures due to their lightweight and high-strength properties. However, fatigue-induced damage, particularly delamination at the skin–stringer interface, poses a significant challenge. The proposed numerical approach, called the “Min–Max Load Approach”, allows for the calculation of the local stress ratio in a single finite element analysis. It represents the ratio between the minimum and maximum values of the stress along the delamination front, enabling accurate evaluation of the crack growth rate. The methodology is applied here in conjunction with the cohesive zone model technique to evaluate the post-buckling fatigue behavior of a composite single-stringer specimen with an initial delamination. Comparisons with experimental data validate the predictive capabilities of the proposed approach.@en

This paper presents the work on six single-stringer specimens manufactured using the card-sliding technique with non-crimp fabrics and adopting a Double-Double (DD) stacking sequence. These specimens, representative of sub-structure level components, are used to investigate post-buckling and failure in aerospace structures. Two specimens maintain a constant thickness cross-section, while four are tapered, two of which incorporate a Teflon insert in the stringer flange. All specimens are tested under compression loading conditions, inducing skin buckling, skin-stringer separation, and eventual collapse. Numerical simulations are validated by experimental results and serve to analyze the specimens behavior and the failure mode. The load versus displacement curves of both experimental tests and Finite Element Method (FEM) analyses are compared, along with the out-of-plane displacement field. Subsequently, the observed failure modes are discussed, focusing on the various mechanisms that occurred and considering the impact of flanges and stiffener tapering. Both the FEM simulations and experimental tests demonstrate good agreement, with the flanges tapering revealing notable results. This offers promising evidence of a viable solution to optimize aeronautical structures and enhance resistance to skin-stringer separation.

@en

Thermoplastic composite welding is a key technology that can help to make the aviation industry more sustainable, while at the same time enable high-volume production and cost-efficient manufacturing. In this work, characterization, testing and analysis of thermoplastic composite conduction welded joints is performed while accounting for the influence of the manufacturing process. Test specimens are designed from welds of a half a meter long welding tool that is developed to weld the stiffened structures of the next-generation thermoplastic composite fuselage. In the design, special attention is paid to the weldability of the laminates, while ensuring fracture occurs only at the welded interface. Two specimen configurations are evaluated for the Double Cantilever Beam and End-Notched Flexure characterization tests. Moreover, Single Lap-Shear specimens are tested in tension and in three-point-bending. Finally, the characterized material properties are introduced in finite element analyses to demonstrate that the cohesive zone modeling approach can be used to conservatively predict the strength of these welded joints. New insights are obtained in the relation between the manufacturing process, the quality of the weld and the mechanical properties of the joints, which are significantly different compared to autoclave consolidated composites.

@en

This research proposes a computationally efficient methodology using a Constrained Variational Asymptotic Method (C-VAM) for non-linear buckling analysis on a hat-stringer panel with delamination defects. Starting with the geometrically non-linear kinematics, the VAM procedure reduces the three-dimensional (3-D) strain energy functional to an analogous 2-D plate model and evaluates the closed form warping solutions. Utilising the resulting warping solutions and recovery relations for the skin and the stringer, displacement continuity at the three-dimensional level is enforced between the stringer and the skin based on the pristine and delaminated interface regions. Consequently, the constrained matrices obtained from C-VAM is incorporated into an in-house developed non-linear finite element framework. Using the developed formulation, a stiffened panel with delamination of 40 mm between the stringer and the skin is analysed under compression. The results have been validated locally and globally, employing experimental data and 3-D finite element analysis (FEA). Experiments are carried out on the co-cured panel by applying quasi-static loading with displacement-controlled conditions, and 3-D FEA is carried out in Abaqus. Load-response plots have been obtained to validate the results at the global level, and they are in excellent agreement with experiments and 3-D FEA. Subsequently, out-of-plane displacement contour plots are obtained; the number of half waves and wave intensity in 3-D FEA and C-VAM are comparable, although there are minor differences compared to the experimental findings. The proposed framework is shown to be computationally efficient by over 55% as compared to 3-D FEA for performing non-linear buckling analysis on the stiffened composite structure considered in the current work.

@en

Conical-cylindrical shells are common geometries in launch-vehicle structures as stage adapters and payload adapters, and they are susceptible to buckling due to their large radius-to-thickness ratios. Buckling design guidance is available but it is limited for conical and cylindrical shells. There is no available buckling design guidance for conical-cylindrical shells. This paper presents the validation of two finite element models used to successfully predict the buckling behavior of a composite conical-cylindrical shell with and without reinforcement tested in two separate campaigns. The laminate design for the first test campaign consisted of a quasi-isotropic layup. For the second test campaign, additional composite plies were applied to reinforce the transition region of the original laminate. The work presented demonstrates the ability to predict the buckling behavior of a composite conical-cylindrical shells with two different designs, which may aid in creating buckling design guidance for conical-cylindrical shells. Additionally, this paper shows that there is no appreciable benefit to adding reinforcement to the transition region if the intent is to increase the buckling load, due to the fact reinforcement brings increased buckling imperfection sensitivity to the shell.@en

Two curved thermoplastic composite multi-stringer panels with roller boundary conditions are analysed and tested to investigate the buckling and failure behaviour. The panels are made of AS4D/PEKK-FC thermoplastic composite, have five stringers with an angled cap on the side and are joined to the skin with the short-fibre reinforced butt-joint technique. The panels have a roller attached to each loading edge, approximating simply-supported boundary conditions to apply compression and bending. One panel has an initial damage representing a barely visible impact damage in one of the stringer butt-joints, and one panel is in pristine condition. Finite element analyses are performed to predict the structural behaviour, and different approximations of the roller boundary conditions are compared. The analyses include material damage initiation and evolution. The out-of-plane displacement of the panels is measured by digital image correlation, and failure is captured with high-speed cameras. The panels fail in a sudden manner when the cap separates from the web, followed by web failure and skin–stringer separation in the butt-joint. The numerical analysis predicts the overall structural behaviour but cannot capture well the sudden panel collapse due to material damage.

@en

Two aeronautical thermoplastic composite stiffened panels are analysed and tested to investigate the buckling behaviour, the skin-stringer separation and the final failure mode. The panels are made of fast crystallising polyetherketoneketone carbon composite, have three stringers with an angled cap on one side, and are joined to the skin by a short-fibre reinforced butt-joint. The panels contain an initial damage in the middle skin-stringer interface representing barely visible impact damage. Finite element analysis using the virtual crack closure technique are conducted before the test to predict the structural behaviour. During the tests, the deformation of the panels is measured by digital image correlation, the damage propagation is recorded by GoPro cameras and the final failure is captured by high speed cameras. The panels show an initial three half-wave buckling shape in each bay, with damage propagation starting shortly after buckling. A combination of relatively stable and unstable damage propagation is observed until final failure, when the middle stringer separates completely and the panels fail in an unstable manner. The test results are compared to the numerical prediction, which shows great agreement for both the buckling and failure behaviour.

@en

This study aims at better understanding the damage tolerance of stiffened composite panels subjected to fatigue loads in the post-buckling regime. Ten single-stringer hat-stiffened specimens with an initial delamination between the skin and the stringer foot were manufactured, and then tested under quasi-static and fatigue loads in post-buckling conditions, with different load levels and load ratios. The tests were monitored with digital image correlation and an ultrasonic system, providing data on the displacements, strains, and extension of the delamination length. The quasi-static results showed that the delamination onset, when the initial delamination begins propagating, occurred at loads over twice the buckling load, while collapse occurred for values almost 20% higher than the delamination onset. During fatigue testing at load levels below the delamination onset, the specimens were able to sustain 150000 cycles and then, when tested statically after fatigue, the average load at collapse was reduced by less than 10% with respect to the quasi-static benchmark. When the maximum load during fatigue was increased to 5% over the delamination onset load, the specimens still withstood between 8000 and 16500 cycles before collapse, depending on the load ratio. It was also seen that for tests at the same load level, the specimens with high load ratio had a slower damage propagation.

@en

Launch vehicle structures, such as payload adapters and interstages, are increasingly designed and constructed using composite materials due to their high stiffness- and strength-to-weight ratios. Therefore, it is important to develop a validated finite element modeling methodology for designing and analyzing composite launch-vehicle shell structures. This can be achieved, in part, by correlating high-fidelity numerical models with test data. Buckling is often an important failure mode for cylindrical shells, and the buckling response of such structures is also often quite sensitive to imperfections in geometry and loading. Hence, it is crucial to understand the model parameters and details required to accurately predict the buckling load and behavior of composite cylindrical shells, especially if the shell is buckling critical. The inclusion of as-built features, such as radial imperfections, thickness variations, and loading imperfections can help improve the correlation between test and analysis. To demonstrate such an approach, a validated modeling methodology that was used to predict the buckling behavior of a scaled component for a launch-vehicle-like structure is presented, and results from the model are compared with experimental results. The modeling approach presented herein was used to successfully predict the buckling behavior.

@en

The work presented in this paper investigates the ability of continuum damage models to accurately predict matrix failure and ply splitting. Two continuum damage model approaches are implemented that use different stress–strain measures. The first approach is based on small-strain increments and the Cauchy stress, while the second approach account for large deformation kinematics through the use of the Green–Lagrange strain and the 2nd Piola–Kirchhoff stress. The investigation consists of numerical benchmarks at three different levels: (1) single element; (2) unidirectional single ply open-hole specimen and (3) open-hole composite laminate coupon. Finally, the numerically predicted failure modes are compared to experimental failure modes at the coupon level. It is shown that it is important to account for large deformation kinematics in the constitutive model, especially when predicting matrix splitting failure modes. It is also shown that continuum damage models that do not account for large deformation kinematics can easily be adapted to ensure that the damage modes and failure strength are predicted accurately.

@en

Launch-vehicle shell structures, which can be comprised of both cylindrical and conical sections, are known to be susceptible to buckling due to their large radius-to-thickness ratios. The advancements in composite manufacturing and numerical methods have enabled designers to consider more nontraditional shapes, such as connecting the conical and cylindrical sections with a toroidal transition to create a single-piece conical-cylindrical shell. This single-piece construction eliminates the need for a heavy interface ring between sections and has the potential to save mass. To better understand the buckling behavior, a composite conical-cylindrical shell was designed, fabricated, and tested. Prior to test, a finite element model that included thickness variations and radial imperfections was created. The test article buckled elastically at 251.8 kN, approximately 8.8% higher than the predicted buckling load of 231.4 kN Continued research in conical-cylindrical structures has the potential to expand the design space for launch-vehicle structures and lead to improved designs and reduced weight.@en

Thermoplastic composite three-stringer panels with omega stiffeners and conduction welded joints are designed, analysed and tested until final failure to investigate the performance of the welded joint in post-buckling. The three-stringer panels are designed to be structurally representative of the fuselage demonstrator of the Clean Sky 2 project STUNNING. A simplified model of the fuselage keel section is analysed by finite element analysis, using the virtual crack closure technique to model skin-stringer separation of the welded joint. The post-buckling and skin-stringer separation behaviour of the fuselage section is then adopted as the reference for the design of the three-stringer panels. Two panels are then tested. The test setup utilises digital image correlation to measure the deformation of the panels, and a high-speed camera to capture the final failure mode. The panels failed in post-buckling due to the separation of the middle stringer, with unstable separation growth followed by separation of the outer stringers and then stringer fracture. The numerical analysis of the panels, with geometrical imperfections included, is able to predict the structural behaviour accurately, with only minor differences in buckling shape and separation behaviour.

@en

This paper presents an experimental investigation on vibrations of heated composite plates leading to thermal buckling. The tests were performed considering two main goals: the application of the Vibration Correlation Technique for the detection of thermal buckling in composite plates; and the exploration of the frequency variations before and after the occurrence of a mode jump in post-buckling regime. Two test setups were used. The setups shared a low thermal expansion frame, while they differentiate on the type of heating source and mechanical boundary conditions. Two composite plates with layups [30/−30/5/−5]_s and [35/−35/10/−10]_s were tested. The plates were excited acoustically using a loudspeaker, and the vibration frequencies were monitored and stored using a laser vibrometer. Buckling temperatures were successfully detected using the Vibration Correlation Technique. Frequency changes, potentially related to the mode jumping, were also detected.

@en

The capability of joining two thermoplastic composite parts by welding is a key technology to reduce the weight and cost of assembled parts and enables high volume manufacturing of future aeronautical structures made of thermoplastic composite materials. However, there is not much experimental understanding of the mechanisms involving welded joint failure, and the computational tools available for the simulation of thermoset composites have not yet been completely assessed for thermoplastic materials. In this work, a numerical and experimental evaluation is performed to investigate the strength and failure behavior of conduction welded thermoplastic composite joints. A welded single lap shear joint is designed, manufactured, tested and analyzed proposing two distinct modeling approaches. A simplified modeling strategy which only accounts for damage at the weld is compared to a high-fidelity model which can take into account the physical failure mechanisms at the lamina level. The high-fidelity modeling methodology is able to predict the experimental failure mode of the investigated welded joints with high accuracy and is used to gain new insights into the key-variables that influence the strength of thermoplastic welded joints. It is also found that the joint strength is highly influenced by the failure mechanisms not only of the welded interface but also of the surrounding plies.

@en

Thermoplastic composites can enable the development of new manufacturing techniques to make the aviation industry more sustainable while at the same time greatly benefit cost-efficient and high-volume production. One of the thermoplastic composite materials that can enable this transition is AS4D/PEKK-FC. In this work, the interlaminar properties of AS4D/PEKK-FC thermoplastic composite are characterized and analyzed by means of Mode I, II and Mixed Mode I/II at 50:50 tests, while considering fiber bridging and R-curve effects. In order to achieve stable crack propagation the test configurations are adjusted to account for the large fracture process zone ahead of the crack tip and an appropriate data reduction method is selected. The experimental data is reduced using an inverse methodology to extract cohesive laws based on only the load–displacement curves. Additionally, the use of this methodology provides new insights into the validity of two different mode II tests and the influence of fiber bridging on the mixed-mode interlaminar behavior. The interlaminar damage mechanisms are investigated by means of scanning electron microscopy. The resulting cohesive laws are implemented in commercial finite element software in tabular form, without the need for user-subroutines. All experimental test configurations are analyzed using a single material card and it is shown that fiber bridging and R-curve effects are well captured.

@en

The effectiveness of carbonaceous nanoparticles in arresting and delaying damage in nanocomposites has been attributed to multiscale toughening mechanisms. To explore their application in joined interfaces of composites, this study investigates the use of carbon nanotube (CNT) interleaved films for co-cured joining of composite parts and their consequent effects on the interfacial fracture toughness. Carbon nanotubes dispersed in a thermoset resin into thin films of two discrete thicknesses (200 μ and 500 μ) and three concentrations of CNT dispersion were chosen for this study (0.5% wt., 1% wt., and 2% wt.). The films were semi-cured in the oven before being incorporated as interleaves in the composite laminate interface. Fracture toughness of the interface in mode I loading conditions was determined through double cantilever beam (DCB). Micrographs of the fracture surfaces reveal a slip-and-stick based crack jump and arrest phenomena in mode I when nanoparticles are added to the interleaved interface. The thickness of the interleaves has a more significant effect on mode I toughening mechanisms than the concentration of the nanoparticles. @en